Re: Rules Question: Stall

On Nov 5, 8:21 pm, Alex Peters <muis...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Nov 5, 7:59 pm, Mark -Mortakai- Moran <just_morta...@xxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

Although you DO know that it's irrelevant when you CALL the foul, but
rather when the foul OCCURS.

Of course, I'm talking about contact occurring during the throwing
motion.  There were two fouls in this game where they accused me of
calling foul then throwing.  The first was a very simple break attempt
with an extremely close mark, I simply leaned towards break, brought
my arm up into his illegally positioned body/arm, called foul and
flipped a completed swing.  This wasn't even remotely close to an
"early call" although I could hear his sideline complaining that I did
just that.  The second was slightly different because I did a spin
move.  I pivoted towards break while cocking my wind up, then
immediately began to pivot back towards the open side (completing a
full counter clockwise circle) while in a throwing motion.  About
halfway through this second half circle, with my arm already moving
towards a throw, I somehow caught, I don't know, a chin? in my
shoulder blade, hard enough that it was sore the next day, I called
foul and jacked a huck up that was incomplete.  I did not pivot, call
foul, pivot then throw.  I don't know which of these two Alex was the
marker on (if either), but on the first we just played on, and on the
second they spent 10 minutes trying to yell at me into retracting my
call.

Technically nobody tried to get you to retract a call, we tried to
explain to you that it clearly was not in the throwing motion and thus
your call had no relevance.

The first one I don't remember at all, the second I remember vividly
because it was pretty bad. I was the mark and I clearly made contact
with you when you tried to break me as I was trying to make up ground
to stop it, then you quickly did a semicircle as you describe and put
up a huck while calling a foul. I told you that you called the foul
on the break pivot and you claimed that your pivoting to the break
side was part of your throwing motion on a force side huck after a
full semicircle. A very bold call on an interesting 3 part throwing
motion (break pivot, semicircle turn, forceside huck)
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Skill vs. Style
    ... calling one or the other foul just because the foul was ... The sole caveat would be that, because of the continuation rule ... If Frank uses the same motion for catching as for the ... So, Frank should call two fouls, just to be certain? ...
    (rec.sport.disc)
  • Re: How dare you, Morgan Hibbert
    ... Foul called. ... Standard Ultimate. ... no contact on hibbert's hand or body during the throwing motion. ... self-officiated game its on you to play within the rules. ...
    (rec.sport.disc)
  • =?utf-8?Q?Re:=202012=20College=20G?==?utf-8?Q?uideli?= =?utf-8?Q?nes?=
    ... hook his elbow as he starts the forward motion of his ... people foul to prevent breaks/hucks. ... throwing motion, but still often a good choice not to call ...
    (rec.sport.disc)
  • Re: Travel on throw because of foul
    ... This question may be slightly off thread but you say a "violent foul" ... before the throwing motion where the thrower chooses to throw it could ... initiate your throwing motion, and how long the contact lasts. ...
    (rec.sport.disc)
  • Re: Rules Question: Stall
    ...  I said I was calling the foul on contact that occurred during ... the throwing motion, which was after I started the second part of the ... pivot. ... I am saying you clearly called a foul on ...
    (rec.sport.disc)