Re: New pick rules with 11th edition

On May 17, 5:19 pm, T <t...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
This is really interesting. If you hear "pick" and see a throw go up
headed towards out of bounds, you should go attempt a legal greatest
to keep possession for your team. (10th edition too, I think)
Conversely, if you hear "foul" on the throw and see that same throw
towards the sideline, you should leave it alone, b/c a legal greatest
means "play on" and your team only keeps it if a teammate catches the
greatest (as opposed to getting it back b/c of the foul on the
throw). Pay attention!

It's not like this comes up very often, but that inconsistency is
likely not intended by the SRC (? maybe it couldn't be avoided)

I wouldn't call these scenarios inconsistent, just strange. We didn't
want the outcomes to be what they are, but we couldn't find a way to
fix them, and left them as-is. I forget why they were tough to fix. It
seems simple. (And I think that's what we thought when we first
discussed them too, with no result.)

Lorne






.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: New pick rules with 11th edition
    ... if you hear "foul" on the throw and see that same throw ... towards the sideline, you should leave it alone, b/c a legal greatest ... I forget why they were tough to fix. ... It's a cool play, but we don't ...
    (rec.sport.disc)
  • Re: First 1.9 experiences
    ... >>Economy on my server, uldum, is out of what b/c of war now, too. ... Yep, same fix here. ...
    (alt.games.warcraft)
  • Re: 2 copies of XP- want to remove the one on the C drive
    ... to remove a bad Norton AntiVirus - long story - so Windows XP ... Am I stuck with it b/c it is on C:? ... can't then I am not sure how to fix the problem of corrupted files- I ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)
  • Suggestions for ridding myself of some malware
    ... watch it, I ran a foul of some Mal Ware. ... I ran A squared and it deleted some stuff but didn't fix the problem. ...
    (alt.comp.hardware.pc-homebuilt)
  • Re: Suggestions for ridding myself of some malware
    ... watch it, I ran a foul of some Mal Ware. ... I ran A squared and it deleted some stuff but didn't fix the problem. ...
    (alt.comp.hardware.pc-homebuilt)