Re: Scar TKO's Top 5 Middleweights of all time..........................

So long as you admit that you ignore pesky things such as facts

Name the facts

Scar TKO
"Charles Beauchamp" <C.E.Beauchamp@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:LY2dnVFchv9g2gvZnZ2dneKdnZydnZ2d@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
TIMOTHY DONATELLI wrote:
Why not explain why your list had, say, Giardello above Cerdan and
Ketchel?

The Arranger


while
forming opinions...


I feel IMO that Giardello could have edged both of those guys out.
However, Ketchel and Cerdan were talented as hell. It's all about
opinion and I rate Giardello higher than Zale or Ketchel.

Scar TKO
"The Arranger" <scrchctc@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1150653505.049778.100780@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

TIMOTHY DONATELLI wrote:
I bet you feel silly not including Tony Zale and Stanley Ketchel.

Nope, I stand by my list. It's all very subjective though.

Scar TKO
"Charles Beauchamp" <C.E.Beauchamp@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in
message news:DeGdnTC2Q9dswgnZnZ2dnUVZ_vSdnZ2d@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
TIMOTHY DONATELLI wrote:
Here are my top 15 middleweights of all-time:

#1): Marvin Hagler - 62-3-2(52)
#2): Carlos Monzon - 87-3-9(59)
#3): Sugar Ray Robinson - 173-19-6(108)
#4): Harry Greb - 106-8-3(48)
#5): Ezzard Charles - 89-25-1(50)
#6): Jake LaMotta - 83-19-4(30)
#7): *** Tiger - 61-17-3(26)
#8): Bernard Hopkins - 47-4-1(32)
#9): Charley Burley - 83-12-2(50)
#10): Joey Giardello - 101-25-7(33)
#11): James Toney - 69-4-3(43)
#12): Michael Nunn - 58-4(37)
#13): Mickey Walker - 93-19-4(58)
#14): Winky Wright - 50-3(25)
#15): Gene Fullmer - 55-6-3(24)

Scar TKO

--
v/r Dread Pirate Rackham

"You know one things that's wrong with this country? Everybody gets a
chance to have their fair say." - President Clinton 28 May 1993

"There is nothing patriotic about hating your country, or pretending
that you can love your country but despise your government." -
President Clinton 5 May 1995



.