Re: Scar TKO's Top 5 Middleweights of all time..........................

TIMOTHY DONATELLI wrote:
Why not explain why your list had, say, Giardello above Cerdan and
Ketchel?

The Arranger


So long as you admit that you ignore pesky things such as facts while
forming opinions...


I feel IMO that Giardello could have edged both of those guys out.
However, Ketchel and Cerdan were talented as hell. It's all about
opinion and I rate Giardello higher than Zale or Ketchel.

Scar TKO
"The Arranger" <scrchctc@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1150653505.049778.100780@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

TIMOTHY DONATELLI wrote:
I bet you feel silly not including Tony Zale and Stanley Ketchel.

Nope, I stand by my list. It's all very subjective though.

Scar TKO
"Charles Beauchamp" <C.E.Beauchamp@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in
message news:DeGdnTC2Q9dswgnZnZ2dnUVZ_vSdnZ2d@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
TIMOTHY DONATELLI wrote:
Here are my top 15 middleweights of all-time:

#1): Marvin Hagler - 62-3-2(52)
#2): Carlos Monzon - 87-3-9(59)
#3): Sugar Ray Robinson - 173-19-6(108)
#4): Harry Greb - 106-8-3(48)
#5): Ezzard Charles - 89-25-1(50)
#6): Jake LaMotta - 83-19-4(30)
#7): *** Tiger - 61-17-3(26)
#8): Bernard Hopkins - 47-4-1(32)
#9): Charley Burley - 83-12-2(50)
#10): Joey Giardello - 101-25-7(33)
#11): James Toney - 69-4-3(43)
#12): Michael Nunn - 58-4(37)
#13): Mickey Walker - 93-19-4(58)
#14): Winky Wright - 50-3(25)
#15): Gene Fullmer - 55-6-3(24)

Scar TKO

--
v/r Dread Pirate Rackham

"You know one things that's wrong with this country? Everybody gets a
chance to have their fair say." - President Clinton 28 May 1993

"There is nothing patriotic about hating your country, or pretending
that you can love your country but despise your government." -
President Clinton 5 May 1995


.