Re: If not original intent
- From: Charlie Board <charlieDIESPAMMERSboard@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 30 Dec 2005 18:52:31 GMT
Edward M. Kennedy wrote:
"Charlie Board" <charlieDIESPAMMERSboard@xxxxxxxxx> wrote
Which brings us back to square one. For example, the first time a case hits that even remotely hinges on the personhood of a corporation do they nuke the whole concept? And watch the economy go boom?
Why? A collection of people can effectively behave like that fictitious legal person (and I suspect it was the legal convenience that led them down this road). At any rate, you would not need to change how the companies are currently set up and behaving in the vast majority of situations. I don't see why not being covered by the BoR is going to hurt a company, especially when the officers and owners of the company are covered.
Get an amendment on the table to take it away from them and if they don't fight it tooth & nail I'll be convinced. Until then...I'll have to settle for thinking you've had a bit too much gin.
You are the drunk arguing society would collapse. Why don't you detail how it would actually happen? All you have provided is vague bullshit.
And you're the one first saying an OI court would probably never get around to doing it and then saying they should do it first time it came up.
And the issue under discussion here isn't the method by which society would collapse in a certain circumstance, but how OI can - in a systematic, logical fashion, which is supposed to be it's strength - deal with the precedence of over a century of non-OI rulings.
Nice try, though.
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Edward M. Kennedy
- Re: If not original intent
- References:
- If not original intent
- From: Edward M. Kennedy
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Charlie Board
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Edward M. Kennedy
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Charlie Board
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Edward M. Kennedy
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Charlie Board
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Edward M. Kennedy
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Charlie Board
- Re: If not original intent
- From: Edward M. Kennedy
- If not original intent
- Prev by Date: Re: Two Lying Presidents......
- Next by Date: Re: College basketball injustice
- Previous by thread: Re: If not original intent
- Next by thread: Re: If not original intent
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|