Re: I like my PRO-43 also, but this is ridiculius!




"Ralph A. Schmid, DK5RAS" <nospam@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:jm6kd19621qtcbee2q577cbl476hk1mlaj@xxxxxxxxxx
> "Jeff" <oldog@(nospam)mchsi.com> wrote:
>
> > Pardon my skepticism but by the time any satellite signal reaches
> >earth you're talking signals in the nanowatt range. Thats the reason why
> >you need a beam and preamp, or a dish with a LNA. And you want
> >us to believe a consumer grade RS handheld can do this feat with
> >just a rubber duck??????? Come on.
>
> It is definetely possible, BTDT. Why should there any difference to my
> satellite handheld phone, which also works just with some flimsy
> antenna?!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

Years ago I bought a Drake TR 270 to do amateur sat. work.
(2mtr. uplink and 440 downlink) when I figured out that I was going
to have to get for an antenna and possibly a dual rotor setup to track
the sat. I dropped the idea. I think at that time you needed a beam
with about 12db of gain for it to work reliably. That translates into
about a 14-15 element dual polarized beam. That is one big antenna.
Plus any mil-sat equipment Ive ever seen invariably use the little
mini dish's to use in conjunction with it. Thats where I got the idea.
I guess things have changed. I know the signals that come down
from space are extremely low power,, with the possible exception
to ISS, I think they may be beaming their signals to earth and running
at a higher power so people can pick them up easily. A geo-synchronous
sat. at 25,000 miles out running on 40-50 watts isnt much power.
The OP gave me some freqs. to try on my VR 5K and Im going to
give it a shot and see what I come up with.. I guess I had a case of
"open mouth and insert foot"

J


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: First TV Broadcast
    ... However, what is the first signal that was broadcast on earth, TV, that was strong enough to get out of the Solar System? ... Earth) could get a picture from the distance of Saturn. ... There have been narrow beam TV signals that could go a lot further, ...
    (uk.sci.astronomy)
  • Re: An Even Better OWLS Experiment.
    ... >> away from Earth at velocity v. ... The Rx/Tx could be circling a Jupiter moon rather than Mars, ... Ghost, Nasa is already receiving very clear signals from Mars. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: An Even Better OWLS Experiment.
    ... >> away from Earth at velocity v. ... The Rx/Tx could be circling a Jupiter moon rather than Mars, ... Ghost, Nasa is already receiving very clear signals from Mars. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: SETI is pointless
    ... you have worked everywhere and at everything on Earth. ... What happens, we see a signal, and turn on the recorder - and the ... don't have any files or records of actual modulated signals - just ... Life arose on Earth almost immediately. ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: laser FM detector
    ... lasers to transmit signals through the laser beam, ... I'm currently stumped in how I would configure the photodiode + AC ... unmodulated laser beam, as MooseFet suggested. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)