Re: Article in Electronic Design


an old friend wrote:
> hot-ham-and-cheese@xxxxxxxxxxx wrote:
> > N2EY@xxxxxxx wrote:
> > > You may have to watch an online ad, but it's worth the wait.
> > >
> > > http://www.elecdesign.com/Articles/ArticleID/11164/11164.html
> > >
> > > 73 de Jim, N2EY
> >
> > Given the millions and millions and millions spent on communications
> > infrastructure...
> >
> cut
>
> > " " "Meanwhile, ham radio operators proved that older technology can be
> > the most reliable technology. Our EDA Editor (and ham) David Maliniak
> > wrote an online column on the subject, pointing out that sometimes "old
> > works when new doesn't." (Read it and add your comments at ED Online
> > 11136.) During and after Katrina, hams running on generators (sometimes
> > with makeshift antennas) worked throughout the hurricane zone to put
> > emergency stations on the air. They guided rescuers to stranded victims
> > and updated weather services via the Hurricane Watch Net." " "
> >
> > Wait a minute. The Guard says their equipment is antiquated and needs
> > replaced, but the ARS service says that older technology may be what is
> > needed.
> >
> > Obviously, they can -both- be right. When wide area vhf+ comm systems
> > go down, they have to switch to simplex where they can, and HF/NVIS
> > networks for the rest of the area.
>
> in point of fact they both can be right
>
> the virtue of Ham radio is we can forge links as we need to the
> downside is by and large we have to every time, the abilty to use use
> the resource is of value when "something that got overlooked shows up"
>
> problems with that senario are the ARS lack much abilty to forge stable
> conections and must invent them continously this is hard for your govt
> and other first responders to use so they gtry to go higher and higher
> tech trying to not to need us

The problem, Markie, is that "higher and higher tech" is EXACTLY
why they have problems that DO need us!

The current circumstances in southern Louisiana are clear proof.
Once again the cellphone net, trunked and interlinked Public Service
communications systems CRASHED under the weight of Katrina.

> ham ego's also get in the way as witness the reaction saying that the
> response of ham radio was less than it could have been while much
> better then the Govt own response

Oh yeah...Our ego's got in the way...yeah. Right. Uh huh. Sure.
OK.

> Yes I am dispointed in the response I saw and heard to Katrina and Rita
> I am apaled by the response of LA and NO not thrilled with FEMA either
> but as can be send they are dependant on the locals for infrastructure

There is no way that any one state can truly "gear up" for the kind
of disaster response that Katrina and Rita mandated...Not even
California with it's sixth or eighth place GNP could withstand this
kind of impact without calling in federal assistance.

Amateur Radio's BIGGEST contribution in this scenario is it's
decentralized locating of assets. With thousands of licessees and
stations spead out over the entire nation, there's no way that anything
short of complete nuclear annihalation, pandemic disease or
apoctolyptic act of God could obliterate it.

Steve, K4YZ

.

Relevant Pages

  • Just to keep you up to date,
    ... abandoning the refugees after katrina, here is a partial list of what ... government to support response and recovery. ... Coast Guard in all of 2003. ... and the Centers for Disease Control and Food and Drug ...
    (alt.politics)
  • Re: No Shame: Jack Kelly Column Littered With Katrina Falsehoods
    ... > It is settled wisdom among journalists that the federal response to the ... > devastation wrought by Hurricane Katrina was unconscionably slow. ... Orleans from Baltimore until four days after the levees were breached. ...
    (rec.music.gdead)
  • Re: Katrina, What Went Right
    ... >>What I do know is that Katrina turned out to be MUCH WORSE than anybody ... > several days in advance of the storm hitting. ... They had initial response ... > think my expectations were 'set too high'. ...
    (misc.transport.road)
  • Re: A piece of his mind....
    ... New Orleans, and the Mississippi Gulf Coast, a record of the effects ... I was confining the commentary to the Katrina situation. ... Brinkley is a history professor while the editors ... the Popular Mechanics article doesn't say the response was ...
    (rec.arts.sf.fandom)
  • Internal Audit: Bushs Homeland Security Dept A Mess!
    ... Audit Finds FEMA Signals Problems at DHS By LARA JAKES JORDAN, ... Weaknesses in FEMA's response system during Hurricane Katrina were ... Homeland Security spokesman Russ Knocke said Wednesday the department ...
    (alt.fan.howard-stern)