Re: GMRS motorola's What's the story?

In article <Xns96D279B1D1BBEPUdstrandattnet@xxxxxxxxx>, Pdigmking
<PUdstrand@xxxxxxx> wrote:

> I'm looking at these GMRS motorolas, one is a t6510xmrs and another is a
> t5520. Here's the thing: both have a power output of one watt, but one
> claims to have a distance range of 8 miles, and the other 5. Is this BS or
> what? Why would one 1 -watt radio have more range than another 1 watt
> radio? They both have the same size antenna.

Paul-

Both are theoretical values for person-to-person communications over level
ground with no obstructions or reflecting surfaces. Since the
communications path is essentially line-of-sight, slight efficiency
differences in power or antenna gain make little difference. Therefore,
the differences must be based on some assumption that was different when
calculations were made.

For line-of-sight, you can approximate the distance to the radio horizon
for each, and add the two for total maximum range. Suppose a person holds
the handheld radio up to their face, and it is five feet above ground.
The distance to their radio horizon in miles, is approximately the square
root of twice the antenna height in feet, or 3.2 miles. Range to another
similar person would be 6.4 miles under these ideal conditions.

You should see that estimating distance based on different heights can
result in differeing ranges. A height of 3.125 feet (sitting down?) has
range of 5 miles, and a height of 8 feet (basketball player?) has a range
of 8 miles to a similar person.

This approach works fairly well from mountain to mountain or airplane.
Based on power and receiver sensitivity, the limiting range might easily
be greater than a hundred miles. In the real world there are reflections
that cancel signals (Multipath), tall objects that block signals and
vegetation that absorbs them. Person-to-person on typical terrain might
easily be limited to less than one mile.

Fred
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: BAd News!
    ... channel 4 stations with a directional outdoor antenna, ... miles away. ... I also received channel 16 from Dayton OH, the full 125 miles distance. ... | would exist at the same power level. ...
    (alt.tv.tech.hdtv)
  • Re: OT spherical trig question
    ... I found 180 miles from a MapSource drawn line. ... Radio line of sight isn't a straight line, and the projection is over 4000 ... depending on frequency the radio horizon range may be different than ... If you use my distance and the precise formula given in your Answers.com ...
    (sci.geo.satellite-nav)
  • Re: Lunar Solar Power Stations vs. The ONeill Proposal
    ... that doesn't demonstrate the efficiency of long:distance power lines. ... "Transmission and distribution losses in the USA were estimated at ... of this plant's power is sent through 40 miles of HV transmission lines ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: How tall should outdoor antenna be?
    ... Most of the stations are ... in SF which is about 40 miles away. ... distance, power, and direction: ...
    (alt.home.repair)
  • Re: Uneven Battery Performance
    ... | power a monitor that shows time elapsed, calories, distance, and miles ... The batteries are most likely not used to power the screen once you get ...
    (alt.home.repair)
Loading