Re: Distributed capacitance effects Q?

On Sun, 29 Apr 2007 06:52:17 -0500, "amdx" <amdx@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

I agree with your assertion that distributed winding capacitance
degrades efficiency.
My thoughts about this are ;
Assume a 10 turn loop, between each turn there is a capacitance,
so, you have a complete circuit, (L,C,R) there is current
flowing through this circuit that is not flowing through the entire 10
turn loop. (this happens in the other 9 turns also)
I think these extra currents flowing that don't make the entire 10
turn circuit increase the losses.

Hi Mike,

Capacitance does not bring loss. Loss ALWAYS resides in Resistance
and nothing else.

Between you and Bill, there appears to be a fixation on the loopS
(emphasis on there being more than one). If you are going to blame
them (that emphasis on there being more than one), and try to tie it
to loss (that emphasis being naturally in Resistance, not
Capacitance); then it follows it is in the natural increase in
conductor Resistance that occurs when wires are spaced closer than 3
or 4 wire diameters to each other. When wires (or loops in this case)
are in close proximity, the magnetic field of the near wire (or loop
in this case, and each loop in proximity to the next) FORCES the
current in that loop to the surface of the wire - INCREASING that
conductor's Skin Resistance. Loss thus increases by proximity.
Capacitance does too, but that is merely a correlating factor.
Remember (and this is good advice, especially suited to Newsgroup
rumors you may pick up): Correlation is NOT causality.

73's
Richard Clark, KB7QHC
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Ground Busses
    ... Someone suggested I write an article on power and grounding techniques ... be no need to worry about power and ground topologies or wire routing. ... By definition, every circuit forms ... strong field from a transformer or choke) exists in the loop, ...
    (rec.audio.tubes)
  • Re: Ground Busses
    ... Someone suggested I write an article on power and grounding techniques ... be no need to worry about power and ground topologies or wire routing. ... By definition, every circuit forms ... strong field from a transformer or choke) exists in the loop, ...
    (rec.audio.tubes)
  • Re: Formula for self-inductance?
    ... You might just as well ask what is the capacitance per square foot of ... But a piece of wire does not. ... you need a loop to ... suggests and compute the mutual inductance from a filament in the ...
    (sci.physics.electromag)
  • Re: Distributed capacitance effects Q?
    ... Assume a 10 turn loop, between each turn there is a capacitance, ... flowing through this circuit that is not flowing through the entire 10 ... or 4 wire diameters to each other. ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: Distributed capacitance effects Q?
    ... Assume a 10 turn loop, between each turn there is a capacitance, ... flowing through this circuit that is not flowing through the entire 10 ... or 4 wire diameters to each other. ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)