Re: Not understanding some parts of wave refraction



On Apr 5, 1:44 pm, "K7ITM" <k...@xxxxxxx> wrote:
Others have posted, correctly, that the propagation velocity is slower
in some mediums than in others. I think it's a mistake, though, to
say that c changes! c is supposed to be a constant, the speed of
electromagnetic wave propagation in a vacuum--in fact, I suppose, in a
vacuum with no gravitational fields in it. A description of fields in
an electromagnetic wave often used the permittivity, epsilon, and
permeability, mu, of the medium through which the wave is travelling.
If it's through a vacuum, the values of epsilon and mu have values
that are used often and have special notation--epsilon-sub-zero and mu-
sub-zero. For convenience here, call them eo and uo. Then note that
eo*uo = 1/c^2. As you might suspect, the propagation in a medium with
larger values of e and u than eo and uo is slower than c. In fact, it
should be velocity = sqrt(1/(e*u)).

Note that e has the units of capacitance/length -- commonly farads/
meter -- and u has the units of inductance/length -- commonly henries/
meter. But a farad is an ampere*second/volt, and a henry is a
volt*second/amp, so the units of sqrt(1/(e*u)) are sqrt(1/((A*sec/
V*meter)*(V*sec/A*meter))) = sqrt(meter^2/sec^2) = meters/sec. A unit
analysis is often useful to insure you haven't made a mistake in your
manipulation of equations.

So...in summary, c = f*w is actually not quite correct. It should be
wave_velocity = f*w. c should be reserved to mean only the speed of
light in a vacuum. If you're in a non-vacuum medium, and measure very
accurately, you'll measure the same frequency, but a shorter
wavelength: the wave doesn't travel as far to push a cycle past you,
as compared with in vacuum. It's going slower.

If the propagation medium is, for example, solid polyethylene (the
dielectric of most inexpensive coax cable), you'll find that w is
about 0.66 times as much as it is in a vacuum, and the propagation
velocity is similarly 0.66*c.

Cheers,
Tom

Thank you everyone! I have a better understanding now. I guess part of
my confusion is that on the same chapter thay have a table on the
electromagnetic spectrum. In it, they list Radio Waves as having
frquencies between 10kHz to 300Ghz and wavelengths of 30,000km to 1mm
(I guess the 30,000 km is a typo in the book). Are these wavelength
values based in a vacuum then?

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Not understanding some parts of wave refraction
    ... It also states that during refraction "the wavelength is ... but the wave frequency (number of crests ... permeability, mu, of the medium through which the wave is travelling. ... If it's through a vacuum, the values of epsilon and mu have values ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: Did Einstein Know Speed of Light Was Variable?
    ... The speed of photon is always c (whether in vacuum ... which depends on the medium and the frequency and can be less (even ... excitations of the medium which generate secondary wave. ... The idea that the phase speed is less than c due to a time lag between absorptin and re-emission by atoms in the medium is a nice idea, but it fails rather badly when the phase speed is>c. As Mati wrote, it _is_ a complex story. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Not understanding some parts of wave refraction
    ... The convenient thing about using medium dependent c in that equation is that we can use things such as index of refraction or velocity factor to convert from vacuum 'c' to 'c' in another medium. ... the speed of an EM wave in any other medium is VF * c where VF is the "velocity factor". ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: Did Einstein Know Speed of Light Was Variable?
    ... The speed of photon is always c (whether in vacuum ... which depends on the medium and the frequency and can be less (even ... Well, that's a complex story. ... excitations of the medium which generate secondary wave. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Lorentz transformation is not correct.Not correct is symetrical form intensity of moving charge.
    ... causing propagation of light. ... Medium is firmly connected with Earth /planets/ - see you ... New definition of medium, in which the light (wave, intensity) ... Earth gravitation field (considering the Earth, ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)