Re: Current across the antenna loading coil - from scratch

Richard Harrison wrote:
Tom, W8JI wrote:
"The directional coupler in a Bird meter samples the across vector
(voltage) from a capacitive divider and adds it to a sample voltage of
the through vector (current) from a current transformer in a
predetermined ratio.

That`s close. In the cartridges is a loop terminated in a diode.
Capacitive coupling of the loop to the center conductor of the precision
ccoax supplies the voltage sample. Inductive coupling of the loop
supplies the current sample.

I`ve described operation several times here and once in this thread, so
I won`t repeat it.


We're all agreed on what happens with the Bird's sampling lines and detector. The only differences arise from each person's attempt to condense it all into a couple of sentences, and aren't worth arguing about.

But Richard cuts it too short when he claims that:
A Bird Thruline wattmeter uses a directional coupler to separate forward direction power from reverse direction power.

That claim confuses two different things: what the line-loop-detector hardware physically *does*; and what the indicated results *mean*. The first of these is agreed; the second is not.

The disagreement is entirely about the interpretation - in other words, it's about the theory about standing and travelling waves. Richard habitually misses out this step, which makes it look as if the Bird wattmeter "proves" the physical existence of forward and reverse travelling waves of power.

It doesn't. Everything that you see printed on the Bird's meter scale, and in the Bird literature, represents that company's particular interpretation of theory about waves on transmission lines. The details of that theory are *not* agreed within this newsgroup, which means that - to some people - the two halves of Richard's claim do not join up.



--
73 from Ian GM3SEK 'In Practice' columnist for RadCom (RSGB)
http://www.ifwtech.co.uk/g3sek
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Birds DONT perch on high-voltage wires
    ... >several times we passed beneath high voltage wires and their associated ... As I gazed at the wires (having ... >bird perching on a high voltage. ...
    (uk.rec.birdwatching)
  • Re: RS-232 levels to computer
    ... Well Richard, you seem to have a lot to say to people on this subject, and with such authority, even though it's actually on topic:) ... Of course this is not within the EIA-232 spec born from it's archaic requirements, but it is within the chip spec and actual system parameters. ... I design production equipment with MAX232's but that is mainly for customer comfort so I can tell them it is "compliant". ... The lowest voltage out of the NPN will be near zero. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: V/I ratio is forced to Z0
    ... "An alternative possibility is that the Bird 43 does give valid readings ... The reverse r-f comes from a reflection. ... voltage to current ratio equal to Zo in each direction of flow. ... double the deflection either would produce alone. ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: Current across the antenna loading coil - from scratch
    ... separate forward direction power from reverse direction power. ... The directional coupler in a Bird meter samples the across vector ... from a capacitive divider and adds it to a sample voltage of ... I can place it in a system with NO standing waves and it will show ...
    (rec.radio.amateur.antenna)
  • Re: Wires crossing overhead my property.
    ... see birds perched on live high voltage overhead power wires (If you do ... them perched on wires, it's because the wires aren't live). ... If a bird settles on a high voltage line the bird will be at the same ...
    (uk.legal)