Re: SCWC 34 Results
- From: Steve Ball <steveb@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Sat, 14 Jul 2007 00:45:46 GMT
Flying Tortoise:
On Jul 13, 10:44 pm, Steve Ball <ste...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Flying Tortoise:
On Jul 13, 3:32 am, Steve Ball <ste...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
Mark Brader
To start with: counterfeiting, rape, impersonation, murder, etc. (5)
Initial letters, &lit.
sb: I like this; the crimes listed are all fairly major indiscretions, and
it finishes nicely with "etc." I like things to be grammatical and I can't
really see that "To start with" = "The starts of", but it's clear what the
intention is, and the whole thing reads well.
Frankly I'm amazed that what you see as a major flaw in others is
dismissed so easily in this entry.
Thanks for sharing that.
I'm generous like that.
"to start with" does *not* = "first
letters of" in this position in any way and the clue as it stands at
best gives an answer of WCRIM with a definition of "etc". In this
order, with "with" and the colon, it's not even an &lit to my mind.
Do I take the absence of comment as agreement or apathy?
I give up; which do you take it as?
Fighting under a flag of truce, is one in war _and_ one out of war?
(5)
AN removed from CRIMEAN
sb: Nice, original idea incorporating probably the most interesting
definition of the lot. "[Something] out of war" suggests removing something
from the middle rather than from the end as is needed here, and "a war"
would better define a particular conflict.
I don't like "one" = A though I'm forced to endure it.
How and by whom?
By not being able to render a completed crossword up otherwise and by
the Listener editor for one.
I absolutely do
not like "one" = AN and nobody has yet seen fit to force me to endure
it.
I've seen both. Shirley, if you're in any way consistent, accepting the one
means you accept the other.
I am entirely consistent in that I 'accept' neither. The Times is
inconsistent in that it allows the one to be used in its published
puzzles and, at least thus far in my experience, not the other
That's a surprise.
Do I take the snipping of the citation of Chambers giving "clime" =
"country" as embarrassment or...er...(another word for embarrassment)?
--
Steve = : ^ )
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: SCWC 34 Results
- From: Flying Tortoise
- Re: SCWC 34 Results
- References:
- SCWC 34 Results
- From: Steve Ball
- Re: SCWC 34 Results
- From: Flying Tortoise
- Re: SCWC 34 Results
- From: Steve Ball
- Re: SCWC 34 Results
- From: Flying Tortoise
- SCWC 34 Results
- Prev by Date: Re: Help please
- Next by Date: Re: PCWC 177 Ballot
- Previous by thread: Re: SCWC 34 Results
- Next by thread: Re: SCWC 34 Results
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|