Re: Forensic Files email reply

On Aug 2, 6:44 pm, David Nebenzahl <nob...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On 8/2/2009 5:58 AM Robert Coe spake thus:

If you want to irretrievably destroy the data on a CD, scrape the
coating off of the "back" side; that's where the information is. The
reader looks through a layer of clear plastic, which effectively
protects the data from damage to the front side. That's why scratches
on the front side usually don't have much of an effect. And why users
 should be more careful not to damage the back side than they usually
are.

Or so I've been told by those who know more about CDs than I do.

Take it from someone who used to work with CDs; you've got it pretty
much correct.

Actually, you don't even need to scratch off much of the coating to make
a CD unreadable and the data unrecoverable; a few well-placed scratches,
especially concentric with the disc, will do the job. That's because
you're destroying most of the data in each track. (This is why users are
advised to clean CDs only by wiping radially--from the center of the
disc towards the edge--rather than circularly; any damage done this way
will be distributed over different tracks, which reduces the risk of
unrecoverable read errors.)

BTW, I'm not sure that DVDs work entirely the same way.

Basically the same way, though as someone else pointed out, DVDs have
multiple layers. Still read from the "bottom" of the disc.

--
Found--the gene that causes belief in genetic determinism

Just so everyone knows, Julie Snodgrass was my mother. Joe Snodgrass
is my father. I am their son. If you guys want real answers about
this feel free to ask me. didjlord@xxxxxxxxxx My name is Joshua
Snodgrass.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Forensic Files email reply
    ... The reader looks through a layer of clear plastic, which effectively protects the data from damage to the front side. ... Actually, you don't even need to scratch off much of the coating to make a CD unreadable and the data unrecoverable; a few well-placed scratches, especially concentric with the disc, will do the job. ...
    (rec.photo.equipment.35mm)
  • Re: Cleaning Fungus
    ... fungus that can destroy ... If you have a mirror in that state, I'd soak it in bleach, and then ... You might want that done by a coating ... or only has coating damage. ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Repair question
    ... Your thoughts are basicly correct, but without some idea what size damage you are facing, I can not be more helpful. ... Use an epoxy that you can get pumps for that way mixing will be no issue. ... each layer of cloth completely overlapping the previous layer until I ...
    (rec.boats.building)
  • Re: Fuck & double fuck
    ... Hit a stone at well over a hundred today, it looks to have taken the ... top layer off only, no damage to the shell as I can see. ...
    (uk.rec.motorcycles)
  • Fuck & double fuck
    ... Hit a stone at well over a hundred today, it looks to have taken the ... top layer off only, no damage to the shell as I can see. ...
    (uk.rec.motorcycles)