Nikon D300 Camera Out performing the Metering System in both A and S Modes

Well I have had my D300 for a day now and I am really getting the hang
of it. One question however for the experts. I am using an 18-200 mm
lens and with the ISO set to 200 and the Camera in "A" (Aperture
Priority Mode) I pointed the Camera at my leather sofa (away from the
light source) and with the F stop set at 3.5 (The shutter read "Lo"
and the analog meter in the view finder was blinking) OK I understand
not enough light for the meter to give me a reading.

I took the picture anyway and it looked good and the histogram was a
little left but acceptable. Next I dialed the ISO to 3200 and then
again to HI-1 and all three of the pictures look OK. Yes the
histogram is to the left but actually the shadows dont look clipped.
Then in Playback I took a look for the shutter speeds and as you would
expect it read, 2, 1/10, 1/20 respectively. So as the ISO when up,
the camera did increase the shutter speed as you would expect.

My conclusion is that the meter could not give me a reading and did
not like the lighting conditions but the camera did its job and took
the picture. I tried this in S Shutter Priority mode and the meter
while still blinking actually showed me how far underexposed I was I
started to adjust until it hit "0" and took the shot. I tried
changing the aperture and it took the pictured but it was all out of
focus since the shutter was open for a very long time.

Is this why people buy separate and really expensive seperate light
meters ? Again it appears to me that the Camera and the Lens can
outperform the meter easily ?

Am I missing something here, I am new at this ?

Thanks to all of you masters.



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Digital Camera Recommendations
    ... It occurs to me you might be interested in the reason I bought a Fuji, ... I was looking for a fast shutter response - i.e. time between pressing ... waterproof camera which uses a mobile-phone type battery, ... although the viewfinder picture ...
    (comp.sys.acorn.hardware)
  • Re: Olympus SP500UZ erratic autofocus
    ... -Custom program the AEL button as AF LOCK ... {camera ready to take picture, press OK/MENU, MODE MENU, CAMERA tab, ... Lock AEL at anticipated location by half pressing the shutter button. ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: The main drawback of a digital camera
    ... >>> as you take the picture where the screen goes black or you're shown ... A mechanical shutter could close immediately ... >>> the blackout period that many or most EVF cameras already have. ... Certainly one of the giant possible advantages of a digital camera is ...
    (rec.photo.digital)
  • Re: Batteries wear out in new camera
    ... so maybe the viewfinder will work as well. ... during the picture taking, like my SLR did before it broke. ... start it up as I'm lifting the camera. ... ??similulated shutter noise??, I see the flash go off. ...
    (alt.photography)
  • Re: Nikon D300 Camera Out performing the Metering System in both A and S Modes
    ... Priority Mode) I pointed the Camera at my leather sofa (away from the ... not enough light for the meter to give me a reading. ... Next I dialed the ISO to 3200 and then ... Then in Playback I took a look for the shutter speeds and as you would ...
    (rec.photo.digital.slr-systems)