Re: Final YouTube for a while - Lowden O23

David Kilpatrick wrote:
Chuck wrote:

Interesting software David. It sounds like it actually transcribes as you play? Does it work very well?



The software works very well. The issues are:

To give the best intonation/note accuracy etc the guitar needs to be set up to run a single midi channel - but for Finale Allegro, each string needs to be received on a separate channel. This is easy enough to do, but it changes the pitch bend behaviour and quantisation slightly, and leads to less than optimal tracking.

Having successfully written the SCORE part in real time as you play, Finale appears to have forgotten which strings were which for the TAB conversion. You can't record into TAB, which would automatically get the fret and string right. Instead, you must paste the score into a new tab stave. While there was string-specific information present at the start, this is now over-ridden, and Finale will select illogical fret/string combinations (or ones it thinks are logical, but are not!).

You then have to edit the tab to restore the correct string, but it's not that bad as when you option-drag the tab note to a new string, it gains the correct fret number for the pitch shown in the score. Since tab and score are not interactively connected, any changes you make in the score need pasting into the tab, and again, probably adjusting.

I have so far nearly completed a tab of Roxburgh Castle in drop D, I'm just listening to some takes of my playing to see whether to change some pedal single string basses to alternating bass (I use both) or write in some ornaments which I omitted when recording.

For nearly all my stuff, I have to slow down for the midi. Half speed. Otherwise there's no chance at all. A lot of clustered fast notes are lost, as I can't slow them down. For example, even at the speed played (slow and careful) the Chinchilla Hop track would not transcribe. If I tried it at my full speed for this, the midi would track so badly I'd just get a muddle of wrong notes.

David
Thanks David.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Practicing pentatonics
    ... If you're playing a note on the 11th fret on your guitar, ... one string up in pitch? ... mental machinations when you play. ... it's the fretboard you're looking at or tab. ...
    (alt.guitar.beginner)
  • Re: For beginners...
    ... As far as learning to play: ... confess I'll use the tab when I see both in front of me (like ... the amount of payback for std notation is probably not so ... I must admit, I did find it interesting knowing which notes I was actually playing, rather than just fret 3, string 1 etc... ...
    (alt.guitar.beginner)
  • Re: Practicing pentatonics
    ... If you're playing a note on the 11th fret on your guitar, do you have to do math to know that you'll get a fifth interval by playing the note that's at the 13th fret, one string up in pitch? ... maybe you do go through these mental machinations when you play. ... Go up one string, add 2, you've got a fifth, whether it's the fretboard you're looking at or tab. ...
    (alt.guitar.beginner)
  • Re: Practicing pentatonics
    ... If you're playing a note on the 11th fret on your guitar, ... one string up in pitch? ... mental machinations when you play. ... it's the fretboard you're looking at or tab. ...
    (alt.guitar.beginner)
  • variable array woes
    ... that corresponds to whichever tab is selected. ... the save Sub creates a text ... I figured the solution would be to create a string ... And the TrackTabs sub is called to do the string variable array: ...
    (microsoft.public.vb.general.discussion)