Re: Progress of the new board

On 2009-06-01 21:59:05 -0400, Bob Lombard <thorsteinnospam@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> said:

Paul Goodman wrote:
On 2009-06-01 12:55:54 -0400, "Frank Berger" <frank.d.berger@xxxxxxxxxxx> said:

Perhaps I missed this somewhere; perhaps it is obvious. But why didn't you
just start a moderated usenet group instead of switching to Yahoo?

Frank, creating a moderated newsgroup in the rec hierarchy is not an easy process. It involves submitting a request for discussion (RFD) to the group <newsgroups. proposals>. There it is discussed and hashed over. They will ask about how you plan to set up the moderation process, who will be responsible, and whether there will be enough traffic to warrant the group. Eventually the big 8 board would vote on whether to create this group or not. If the group passes it will not change rmcr, it would remain unmoderated, but it would form a competing group with a different name. Not a good idea in my opinion as it would splinter this group just as the yahoo group is doing.



It doesn't 'splinter' this group. The faint-hearted will leave, the explorers will read both boards, the reactionaries will stay, the A&Ts will be here until the dysentery gets them.

bl

If the faint-hearted leave, then it splinters this group. People can and do whatever they want, but let's not pretend that it won't affect what is being posted on rmcr. I guess I am in the reactionaries category.

--
Paul Goodman

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Progress of the new board
    ... creating a moderated newsgroup in the rec hierarchy is not an easy process. ... They will ask about how you plan to set up the moderation process, who will be responsible, and whether there will be enough traffic to warrant the group. ... Not a good idea in my opinion as it would splinter this group just as the yahoo group is doing. ...
    (rec.music.classical.recordings)
  • Re: Progress of the new board
    ... creating a moderated newsgroup in the rec hierarchy is not an easy process. ... They will ask about how you plan to set up the moderation process, who will be responsible, and whether there will be enough traffic to warrant the group. ... Not a good idea in my opinion as it would splinter this group just as the yahoo group is doing. ...
    (rec.music.classical.recordings)
  • Re: Suggest Moving SAA
    ... Yahoo is no solution. ... in order to "preserve the positive image" of the ... anything is put under strict moderation and not allowed to post without ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)
  • Re: Progress of the new board
    ... didn't you just start a moderated usenet group instead of switching ... They will ask about how you plan to set up the moderation ... would splinter this group just as the yahoo group is doing. ... usenet newsgroup. ...
    (rec.music.classical.recordings)
  • Re: Dear comp.dcom.telecom Readers
    ... > I thought this was a moderated newsgroup. ... It is, but it's not hard to get around the moderation requirement, due to a ... And Steve, I know you are running r.r.b. ... Airwaves.com web site about the problems he is/was having with the IP ...
    (comp.dcom.telecom)
Loading