Re: Sor/Segovia #1, again

On Aug 5, 2:25 pm, Dicerous <dicer...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Aug 5, 6:15 am, Dicerous <dicer...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:





On Aug 5, 5:46 am, Tommy Grand <howardj...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

On Aug 4, 4:38 pm, "Alain Reiher" <rei...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

I do not want to be on your back but I would love to hear a
version with the AG recommendation about the appogiatura in mm 12 to 16 I
agree with him that the short one sound like a hic up!

Hmm, I guess I like the appogiatura better than the 8th notes.
Besides, since MO and AG differ on this question I must side with MO
(because I fear him).  BTW if you want to hear a version like that,
check out the sound file on the Italian page linked in my original
post.  That player does it w/8th notes.

Mo just happens to be correct this time around.  Don't fear him, fear
the people that find complexity in simple forms.  That's an example of
territorialization.  These are the same people that find Mondrian or
the suprematists *complex*.  This is hardly the case.

David

Here's a good hypothetical about *complex forms*.  On a final, the
philosophy professor asks one question.  The students open their
little blue books, get out their pencils and he writes on the
blackboard:  WHY?

One student writes down WHY NOT! And walks out of the room.

How should the professor grade this?

David

(It's not actually a hypothetical, this happened at University of
Vermont...and I know the grade the student got....)


David
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Uncle Al has Aspergers syndrome
    ... you sound like year 1 student with underprivileged background. ... I am expert in behavior science. ...
    (sci.chem)
  • Re: Uncle Al has Aspergers syndrome
    ... you sound like year 1 student with underprivileged background. ... I am expert in behavior science. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Rules of thumb for creating lines
    ... But when a student asks you "how do I make up lines that sound good" ... Tell your students to listen to the great masters of modern jazz. ... things up so that the computer will improvise lines over various harmonies. ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.jazz)
  • Re: Late beginner advice?
    ... For Paul Desmond's sound, head for an Alto student model - maybe a YAS-275 from Yamaha. ... 500 UK pounds. ...
    (rec.music.makers.saxophone)
  • Re: Sor/Segovia #1, again
    ... version with the AG recommendation about the appogiatura in mm 12 to 16 I ... (because I fear him). ... check out the sound file on the Italian page linked in my original ... philosophy professor asks one question. ...
    (rec.music.classical.guitar)
Loading