Re: Geoff Emerick claims: A Day In The Life


<tom@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1152679212.898829.169640@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Sixties Gen wrote:
It's John.

The last time we had this discussion, a couple of months back...someone
found a very reliable source(Sir George, perhaps?) who said it was
John.

It has always sounded like John since I first heard the song playing in
my ears 39 years.

Still sounds like John to me.

There are no reliable sources. Your ears are the best source.

Emerick, all of them...misremember on a regular basis. When the new
book "Recording The Beatles" comes out, you'll get as close to truth as
you ever will. Sometimes multiple people at the SAME session
contradicted each other when interviewed for Brian's book. Soon, no one
will remember anything. ;)

Paul actually told me that the guitar playing the lead in "Nowhere Man"
was a Gretsch (it wasn't)...and that was only a couple years after they
had done the record.

"Ears....now they're real important too..." ---James Caan,
"Rollerball."

TH


....the voice of reason speaks! And these fine people are trying to remember
things that happened 40 years ago... with grey cells that are a little
shop-worn.

....I can't wait for THE BOOK to show up at my door.

8^)

dave (...indicate precisely what you mean to say...)
www.Shemakhan.com


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Geoff Emerick claims: A Day In The Life
    ... It has always sounded like John since I first heard the song playing in ... There are no reliable sources. ... Your ears are the best source. ... book "Recording The Beatles" comes out, you'll get as close to truth as ...
    (rec.music.beatles)
  • Re: No Paul Single from Abbey Road?
    ... at least John and Paul respected each othe'rs ... John wanted to release "Revolution 1" as a single, but was told "No, ... This prompted the recording of the fast version, ...
    (rec.music.beatles)
  • Re: Recording (from cassette/turntable) to a PC
    ... but doesn't anyone make a sound card with line level ... > Cheers John. ... >> compression to a weak recording. ... >>> Some time back I bought a little Creative Labs SoundBlaster gadget ...
    (alt.guitar.bass)
  • Re: I FEEL FINE...feedback
    ... engineer who was in the recording studio with the Beatles. ... John, Paul George or Ringo... ...
    (rec.music.beatles)
  • Re: YOU be the judge.
    ... If memory serves, John, Arnie *always* lives up to your expectations. ... 220 to 1 against JA actually receiving a recording ... Arny made a promise. ...
    (rec.audio.opinion)