Re: Performers I Just Don't Get (and Never Got)


"A to Z" <THECAPSaddietzARE@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:5v6chfF1k1u7jU1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

"Robert Wiersema" <robwISNTAThome@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:sBmjj.77884$EA5.63873@xxxxxxxxxxxx

"Willy Eyenine" <billyeye9@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:EYydndqyRdSTMBDanZ2dnUVZ_tqtnZ2d@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx

"Robert Wiersema" <robertwiersema@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in
message
news:1iar8yg.1tsivva19ykj7sN%robertwiersema@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
<Patrick1765@xxxxxxx> wrote:

On Jan 14, 6:14?pm, "stuthalb...@xxxxxxxxxxx"
<stuthalb...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Aerosmith

They had one great album IMO Permanant Vacation. After that they
just became repetitive.

Wow... that's a... I'm speechless.

You are aware that Aerosmith existed prior to the 1980s, right?

Nirvana

I never got Nirvana or Pearl Jam.... just not my type of music I
guess.

Well, typeS of music, I suppose - Nirvana and PJ are as different as
the
Sex Pistols and Springsteen...

And why is it that every song Led Zeppelin ever did is a Classic
Rock
staple, including the Drum Solo, yet Deep Purple are mostly
forgotten
except for "Hush, "SOTW," "Highway Star," "Space Truckin'" and
"Woman
From Tokyo"?


You can't compare Deep Purple to Led Zeppelin, Zeppelin created
Metal.


No, they really didn't.

If anyone can be credited with "creating" heavy metal, it would have to
be Black Sabbath. Zeppelin weren't a metal band at all.

I think LED ZEPPELIN II would beg to differ...

I don't.
Put zep II up against Paranoid - there's really no comparison.


well, according to wikipedia, the first known use of the term "heavy
metal" to describe a band was about Humble Pie, " In the November 12,
1970, issue of Rolling Stone, he commented on an album put out the
previous year by the British band Humble Pie: "Safe As Yesterday Is, their
first American release, proved that Humble Pie could be boring in lots of
different ways. Here they were a noisy, unmelodic, heavy metal-leaden
shit-rock band with the loud and noisy parts beyond doubt. There were a
couple of nice songs...and one monumental pile of refuse." I don't think
he liked it. Of course, since LZ had already released an album by then,
that does not really affect their status as "first" - or not.

They also state that Blue Cheer's cover of Summertime Blues, in 1968, was
the first heavy metal recording (single), followed shortly thereafter by a
single from the last of the Yardbirds (soon to be LZ). They also cite
In-A-Gadda-Da-Vida, as the first metal album (this was the first album I
thought of as well. Never heard of Blue Cheer).

from other sources than wikipedia:
Rock critics and other people with too much time on their hands will
forever debate the pre-Black Sabbath origins of heavy metal -- we hear
you, Blue Cheer fans! -- but anyone operating within the ever-expanding
boundaries of that genre owes a debt to Birmingham, England's finest
export. (Tampa Tribune, 9/14/07)

It seems fitting that many pop music historians pinpoint the origin of
heavy metal rock to the power trio Mountain. Launched in the
flower-power-drenched late 1960s, the Long Island, N.Y., band had both an
aural and physical presence unlike any band before it. (St. Petersburg
Times, June 2, 2007)

In a sweeping look at the origins of heavy metal, Dunn paints composer
Wagner as one of the godfathers of metal... (that is Wagner as in opera,
etc.) Courier Mail (Australia), November 23, 2006)

The received wisdom is that the Jeff Beck Group's Truth album of 1968 is
the first real heavy rock/metal album but, in terms of sheer impact, that
honour surely must go to the 1969 Led Zeppelin. Since then the music had
been distorted and fragmented out of all recognition. One consistent thing
though: as a genre it remains - and stubbornly so - largely a white, male,
teenage phenomenon. The Irish Times, September 10, 2004

a lot of people also credited the Kinks, in 1964 or so, with first
creating (?) the power chords and distortion that led to metal. From the
same Irish Times article:
"The first five notes of The Kinks' You Really Got Me single marked the
beginning of heavy metal. Strange but true. Here's how it happened: when
Ray Davies wrote You Really Got Me, brother Dave was charged with coming
up with the intro. The first few times he hacked something out, his
girlfriend of the time told him the playing was good but it didn't make
her "want to drop her knickers".

To produce something a bit more rasping and distorted, Dave Davies went
over to his little amplifier and cut the cone up with a razor blade. The
vibration of the fabric produced a hitherto unheard "fuzz" sound and those
five notes became one of the most legendary riffs in music. The irony of
it all was that, originally, Ray Davies played the intro on a piano, and
he thought he had come across a jazz riff.

An urban myth grew up around this intro. To this day, a large proportion
of Led Zeppelin fans will tell you that it was Jimmy Page (who, back in
1964, was a noted session guitarist) who played the riff. While Page did
play on some Kinks records, he had nothing to do with this song."

Yeah, I would have gone for Iron Butterfly as proto-heavy metal as well.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Voices of a Generation
    ... decade since the 1950s was preposterous: Music is entirely subjective, album ... It's hard to believe that before the 1950s, rock and roll as we know it ... No band in history has ever done that so effortlessly and so ... If Jimi Hendrix was the first guitar god, the members of Led Zeppelin were ...
    (rec.sport.pro-wrestling)
  • Re: My web page still kicking major major ass (added two more para)
    ... Before them it was Beatles and Rolling Stones slugging it out from the ... the first year of psychedelic rock and album rock, ... Led Zeppelin would come back big in 1975 with their ... the biggest band in the world'. ...
    (rec.music.beatles)
  • Re: Performers I Just Dont Get (and Never Got)
    ... They had one great album IMO Permanant Vacation. ... You can't compare Deep Purple to Led Zeppelin, ... British band Humble Pie: "Safe As Yesterday Is, ... was a noted session guitarist) who played the riff. ...
    (rec.music.artists.springsteen)
  • The best Paul interview Ive read in a long time.
    ... PAUL STANLEY ON, SONIC BOOM, & LIFE ... philosophy behind the new album, his relationship with Gene Simmons, ... I think the band has become so, so strong live, with the lineup that's ... ARE THERE DIPLOMATIC SKILLS INVOLVED IN TELLING GENE TO MOVE OVER SO ...
    (rec.music.artists.kiss)
  • Re: Mr. MoJo RiSiNg.
    ... Simple Minds performing in Oslo, ... Simple Minds are a Scottish rock band who achieved worldwide popularity ... The core of the band is the two remaining founder members - Jim Kerr ... The first Simple Minds album, Life in a Day, was produced by John Leckie ...
    (rec.sport.pro-wrestling)