Re: End of the year topic.. sort of.. :)




"Badger_s" <Badger_s@xxxxxxxxx> replied in message
news:n8gbr11ns7diej80qbhvbtejgq24holdl6@xxxxxxxxxx
clipped

> In my experience it's almost impossible to apply all but the most
> elementary strategic thinking during the 'free-fighting' range of
> one-on-one fighting. The action is too fast, reactive and 'chaotic', imo.
> Most of the time, I'm thinking 'bridge the gap' and 'attack, attack,
> attack'. ;-)
>
> However, in the standing grappling/clinch fighting range, especially when
> setting up and performing judo throws, I can see where a big part could be
> played by strategic thinking. You're working on getting the opponent to
> step a certain way, trying for the off-balancing move. (I'd think most of
> this would be worked out in the dojo before competition such that during
> actual performance it's more instinctive).
>
> Perhaps one of the judo players here could comment.
>
> Of course in ground-fighting I also see this but not in a 'thinking' sense
> - it is in the 'instinctive' realm, where you're flowing from
> counter-to-counter. Or it should be instinctive. Part of the process
> leading up to this ability would certainly be of a strategic nature,
> though. Or maybe that's a very early and elementary phase of learning. The
> more you 'think' the slower and less flowing you are, I'd guess, causing
> an
> actual inhibition of your physical progress.

Yes, I think you're quite correct, Badge. Within the flow however there is a
strategy that is akin to chess...a 'branching' that most are familiar with.
Understanding the possibilities (breadth) and where they chain to (depth)
gives you an ability to 'see' the board better and know where the game is
going.

> I've mentioned before that I think the better bjj players must have a type
> of innate 3-D perception of the body in space such that they can see
> various alternate moves. For instance, the anaconda and brabo chokes are
> really just turned around aspects of other more common moves.

No doubt.

Going from a
> RNC position to an armbar is also a 'rotation in space' kind of mental
> move. Certainly Eddie Bravo's Twister is an extreme example of this,
> especially when he 'rolls over' to get a better position in some
> variations.

Yup.

> So I think the repeat 'playing' of this strategic game just develops the
> timing that's essential to pulling it off. The best players anticipate and
> flow, preventing the opponent from getting a move locked in.

'Fight as you train' again, eh?

> Obviously in the heat of combat, there's not a lot of conscious, logical
> thinking going on. The timing is innate by then.

Usually...but a degree of anticipation will help too. If you know something
is going down soon, surveilling your environment for allies, adversaries,
possible weapons, routes of escape etc will buy you a big advantage.

Bas Rutten has done some interesting stuff on this, well worth a look.

Cheers

GDS





.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Question for Silat Guys: Is This Good Silat?
    ... And most include weapons. ... Older guys could specialize in judo and compete, ... My own system contains a 'kendang' aspect- a 'formalized' fighting ... We train to 'attack the guns'- to try to injure the means of his attack. ...
    (rec.martial-arts)
  • Re: OT-Surprised they didnt see this coming.....
    ... Our civilian population will be fighting them in our streets, instead of our trained soldiers fighting them in Iraq. ... To some of us, when we are attacked, even by only a handful of attackers, it would be considered a "battle" in the war against terror, and we would like to WIN the battle to stop WORLD WIDE terrorism. ... You side with the enemy and want us to pull out of the war that we didn't start, and can't end with anything short of complete and total victory. ... So why would you side with the enemy when you know full well how they will attack us, and that they most certainly WILL attack us. ...
    (rec.outdoors.rv-travel)
  • Re: An interesting encounter with Horde
    ... For me, though, there's just no fun in fighting other players. ... And it was a bit of an adrenaline rush. ... Some 68 level Mage was running ...
    (alt.games.warcraft)
  • Re: Funny PvP story
    ... I'm in felwood with my warrior fighting some of the demons for ... I look around and see a warlock a level above me waving. ... He starts fighting and I'm still considering the morality of allowing ... thinking, ok, it'd be really low to attack now. ...
    (alt.games.warcraft)
  • Fighting vs Self-Defence
    ... against a potential violent attack. ... neccessary to differentiate between "fighting" and self-defence, ... where the intention of both parties is to "win" the fight, or at worst, ... I'd sucker punch and then get the hell out of there asap! ...
    (rec.martial-arts)