Re: Treestand Etiquette



Mike Marlow <mmarlowREMOVE@xxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> In my opinion, it's never ethical to do so. Sure - the hunter may be
> on land he shouldn't be on and that should be addressed - as long as
> you are certain he has no right to be there. But stealing is
> stealing and stealing a guys stand is not justified by his being on
> private hunting property.

Legally, taking the stand is NOT stealing. When he put the stand on
land he did not own (or had permission to use), he *legally* forfeited
the ownership of the stand (to the landowner).

What's more, it doesn't even have to be on private property where he is
poaching. I don't know about other states, but in Texas, if you put up
a stand on public property (ie. build a duck blind in the coastal
marshes), that blind is at that point OWNED by the state (public).
Anyone can use it. They could even dismantle it and relocate it
somewhere else.



> What do you mean by private hunting
> property, anyway? Is it a lease lot? Land that you have the
> landowner's somewhat exclusive permission to hunt? Where I'm going
> with this is to find out if it's possible the other hunter might
> indeed have permission to be there.

As everyone else said, yes, this is the first step - find out FOR SURE
if it belongs to anyone that has permission to hunt there. But if they
don't, not only can you remove it - you SHOULD remove it.

--?

+ + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + + +
Chris Barnes AOL IM: CNBarnes
chris@xxxxxxxxxxxx Yahoo IM: chrisnbarnes

You always have freedom of choice, but you never have freedom of
consequence.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Treestand Etiquette
    ... But stealing is stealing and stealing a guys stand is not justified by his being on private hunting property. ... land he did not own (or had permission to use), he *legally* forfeited the ownership of the stand. ... You always have freedom of choice, but you never have freedom of ...
    (rec.hunting)
  • Re: Treestand Etiquette
    ... But stealing is stealing and stealing ... a guys stand is not justified by his being on private hunting property. ... Land that you have the landowner's somewhat exclusive permission to hunt? ...
    (rec.hunting)
  • Re: Hobbit House and Dale Farm - Retrospective Permission
    ... They bought land ... >>> they knew at the time they bought it had no planning permission ... >>> bound by planning law. ...
    (uk.legal)
  • Re: Tips when allowing strangers to hunt my land?
    ... them rights and some rules such as no cutting wood to carry off the land ... stands like no nailing wood into trees, metal foot pegs in trees are ... let hunters/wildlife officers enforce it yourself so other hunters or hikers ... requesting permission to deer hunt on the property. ...
    (rec.hunting)
  • Re: Oregon property lines near public roads
    ... like to infer that they own the land ... ... I see a lot of cases where there is a series of transfers to PennDOT ... I wouldn't agree to the land being used for horses. ... Trespass is usually defined as use without permission. ...
    (misc.rural)