Re: South African moratorium

Sean

If I might respond as follow;

* Prior to August 2004 the moderation was done by one individual. Now
there is a team of moderators and nothing is "pulled" without
consultation first.
* The subject of Scottish Feudal Barons and their heraldic additaments
are subject that seem to cause heated debate especially post the
appointed day.
* The forum of the Heraldry Society of Scotland is a shop window on the
Society, its membership and activities. The discussion of heraldry can
produce differing opinions and arguments. So long as these are
conducted in a gentlemanly way, all is well. No society permits stand
up slanging matches in their meetings, so why should they in their
forums?

For those who wish to have a venue for their unshackled thoughts there
is, of course, rec.heraldry. However, if rec.heraldry were a heraldic
society, given the recent personal attacks posted here, would anyone
what to join and meet with some of the correspondents here?

Yours aye

Stephen

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: South African moratorium
    ... Prior to August 2004 the moderation was done by one individual. ... The forum of the Heraldry Society of Scotland is a shop window on the ... Society, its membership and activities. ... I will just say that from my point of view the HSS Forum is rather too restricted, as without freedom of discussion frauds like Mac Carthy Mór or Prince Michael of Albany cannot be exposed. ...
    (rec.heraldry)
  • Re: What Happened to this Group???
    ... wide openess of the forum. ... heraldry deserves colour and closed groups such as the ... Heraldry Society of Scotland forum or the American Heraldry Society ...
    (rec.heraldry)
  • Re: What Happened to this Group???
    ... wide openess of the forum. ... Heraldry Society of Scotland forum or the American Heraldry Society ... plently of private forums open to myself, ...
    (rec.heraldry)
  • Re: Assumption of standard
    ... I have looked at the website of the American Heraldry Society. ... See para 1.0 of the guidelines: ...
    (rec.heraldry)
  • Re: its the new guy with another problem
    ... Names and terms that imply relationships between Society members (such as ... >>belt which appears to be a squire's belt. ... >October 1998 where the protected regalia are identified. ... It was not part of heraldry, because it is dress, ...
    (rec.org.sca)