Re: Does cedar mulch kill plants and shrubs???


Wolf Kirchmeir sockiescat wrote:-
i have read so many things that say that cedar mulch slowly kills
plants
and shrubs by leeching the nitrogen and nutrients out of the soil.
i was wondering what anyones opinion would be on this as i had
thought
of using cedar mulch around my spireas, hostas and a lot of other
things
that i am hopefully going to get planted this fall and now im am
wondering
if i would be better off not adding it to the beds :(.
any input would be greatly appreciated. i dont want to make a huge
mistake :(.
thanks again, sockiescat:).-

First, check on whether hostas etc want acid or neutral or basic
9alkaline) soils. I'm not going to do the search for you: use Google.
You will learn how to use that amazing resources, and information you
find for yourself tends to stick better than information someone else
has found for you. Beware! Googling can become a hobby in itself --
even
an addiction. :-)

Having said that, I'll give you some information anyway. Consistent I
am
not. :-) Who was it said "Consistency is the bugaboo of small minds"?

Cedar mulch acidifies the soil, so it can be bad for most of the plants

we grow in our gardens, which prefer neutral or even slightly alkaline

soils. However, slightly acid soils won't harm them, so mixing cedar
cuttings into the mulch won't hurt. If you're worried about the
acidifying effect, add some agricultural limestone to the mix, or
sprinkle some on top of the mulch.

However, cedar and other evergreen mulches are good for rhododendrons,

for example, and of course for any evergreen tree or shrubs, all of
which prefer acid soils. Hydrangeas tolerate both acid and basic soils;

in fact, they produce different coloured flowers depending on pH (the
measure of acidity/alkalinity.)

NB that acid fertilisers are available, they're usually marked "for
evergreens" or some such. Read the label.

You should have a soil analysis done on your garden, so you have a
general idea of what kind of soil(s) you have. Kits for home use are
available, and in some states and provinces the local agricultural
support agencies will do an analysis for free or a nominal cost. You
could also google on "soil types".

HTH

thanks for the information wolf u answered what i needed to know as to
whether it would harm the plants or not so i will look for another way
to add a mulch but will also mix the cedar into whatever else i use as
a top dressing and include some lime as well;).
i did look on google thats where i got the information that i included
here some people said that it was bad and others said it was okay so it
was rather confusing which way to go :( and at the cost of some of my
plants i sure didnt want to be making any stupid mistakes and end up
losing them :(.
so thanks again for your input and yup i will get a soil sample kit
also and see whats there and whats not ;). cyaaaaa, sockiescat:).




--
sockiescat
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Soil Acidity
    ... the local water skewed the true reading, is this likely, the water on ... Anyhow, should it be required, what do you add to the soil to make it ... That certainly helps with some acid loving shrubs and trees but it does ... plants never do that well. ...
    (uk.rec.gardening)
  • Re: All those lawn doctors out there
    ... the soil was too sweet if there is such a thing? ... state) often have soil test kits and loads of info about lawn care. ... alkaline and soil with lots of leaf waste tend to be acid. ... Too alkaline can cause plants to not take up nutrients. ...
    (alt.home.repair)
  • Re: Urban renewal on the west side of the pond...
    ... :for the soil but make the plants grow big and strong. ... :Come look at our fields and tell me where all this mass erosion is ... Never heard of having to add acid to the soil ...
    (soc.culture.scottish)
  • Re: Urban renewal on the west side of the pond...
    ... :for the soil but make the plants grow big and strong. ... :Come look at our fields and tell me where all this mass erosion is ... Never heard of having to add acid to the soil ...
    (soc.culture.scottish)
  • Re: Class B cannabis
    ... Cover the soil around the plant with a thick layer of natural mulch to ... attract condensed water and to keep soil moisture from evaporating. ... Transplant seedlings or clones in spring and grow marijuana plants as you ... Vansterdan has been planting in the mountains for 12 years in secret gardens ...
    (uk.politics.drugs)