Re: Can the banes be made useful?



In article <1123188896.081275.239230@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, John
H. says...
> ...
> Kidding aside, by the time you reach demons other than *cubi and water
> demons, you probably already have a much better artifact weapon than
> Demonbane. Demonbane's damage bonus is x2 weapon damage (longsword:
> d8/d12) against demons. Excalibur's is +10 to damage, always better
> against small and medium foes, and usually better against large ones.
> But an _ordinary_ silver saber does an extra d20 damage to demons, and
> if that saber happened to be Grayswandir....
> ...
> - John H.

Demonbane doubles enchantment damage (and strength damage?) too. From
art2-343.txt, at +7 it does greater average damage to demons than
anything bar Frost Brand (equal) and Grayswandir. FB is unaligned
whereas GS and DB are Lawful, so for non lawful characters with lots of
enchant weapon scrolls and ignoring weapon skills GS>FB>DB for demon
killing.

Perhaps Demonbane should be unaligned?
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Getting rid of Yeenoghu
    ... right now my main weapon is a +6 Mjollnir. ... Stormbringer is just an ordinary runesword against demons. ... Yeenoghu is a large demon. ... At Str 18 a wizard does the following damage to Yeenoghu: ...
    (rec.games.roguelike.nethack)
  • Re: Demonbane v. Firebrand (spoilery)
    ... My main weapon is the +6 Mojo (stupid ... Mojo does base damage of 3.0. ... Fire Brand is just an ordinary long sword vs fire resistant monsters. ... All demons are fire resistant, ...
    (rec.games.roguelike.nethack)
  • Re: Can the banes be made useful?
    ... > rustproof Demonbane is a mighty useful weapon already, ... > damage against all demons and as a long sword is a good general-purpose ... Demonbane's damage bonus is x2 weapon damage (longsword: ...
    (rec.games.roguelike.nethack)
  • Re: what to twoweapon? (spoiled)
    ... That's why the artifact selection spoiler ... ranks artifacts by average damage vs demons. ... popcorn monsters, and I'd much rather optimize for damage against them. ...
    (rec.games.roguelike.nethack)
  • Re: what to twoweapon? (spoiled)
    ... most overall damage. ... Not vs Vampires. ... and all demons except tengu. ... You'd have to enchant to katana to +15 to match that. ...
    (rec.games.roguelike.nethack)