Re: AFM or POTC

On Mar 31, 3:02 pm, "baraka" <grus...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Mar 31, 2:58 pm, "Pin Wiz Jr." <maizeandb...@xxxxxxx> wrote:





POTC looks nice. AFM looks nice and plays nice. It's just that simple. I'm
not a big Stern fan, so maybe I'm biased, but it feels like whenever I play
it, I just bash the ship over and over again. Just not much of a challenge
when it takes 4 games to get to Four Winds (I know there's gauntlet, but it
shouldn't be that easy to get to pre-wizard mode).

-Ethan Blonder
--www.fspazone.orgwww.virginiapinball.org

"pinballzmylife" <silverball...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message

news:1175363422.675871.170590@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

I am up in the air on this one.. Someone please chime in, and let me
know, If you owned pirates, would you trade it straight up for AFM? I
really want to do it, but my girl says I am stupid if I do.. What
would your choice be on this one??

I own an AFM and POTC. Both are different. Different rules, different
game play. AFM is definitely cool and not going anywhere from my
gameroom. POTC I'm not sure yet. I love this game and the only reason
I wouldn't sell it because I like it too much. But, I may entertain a
trade for a MM or a CV. Before I do this though, I think I need to
play these 2 titles to see if I really like MM or CV. I played MM and
loved it, but now it's time to really play it before I trade. If I had
room for just one more pin, POTC would not leave my house, that's for
sure. This is a great looking and playing pin and very hard to finish.
Very challenging too. I have to honestly give AFM the thumbs up over
POTC, but not by much. Both are very unique. It's a hard call for me
on this.
John- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

If you get the AFM home and don't like it or your girl gives you a
hard time about it. I am sure you could trade it for another POTC no
problem.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Trade value of a nice AFM
    ... somewhat different style of play.. ... Figure a nice AFM will fetch 3500+ so pretty much opens you up to any ... I would say keep the AFM and trade the BSM but I am a B/W snob so ... Agreed, you'd better think long and hard before trading off that AFM, ...
    (rec.games.pinball)
  • Re: Opinions: Trade AFM for a Safecracker
    ... years ago and it was too loud to know what I was doing. ... I have something similar to AFM. ... to form an opinion or go for the trade. ... play some more on the SC, but don't want to miss out on a good trade ...
    (rec.games.pinball)
  • Re: Trade value of a nice AFM
    ... enjoying the SM and personally think it is a better game...The play is ... somewhat different style of play.. ... Figure a nice AFM will fetch 3500+ so pretty much opens you up to any ... trade with cash coming your way except for a few titles. ...
    (rec.games.pinball)
  • Re: Who doesnt like their POTC? Wanna trade it?
    ... If you want to trade your AFM for a POTC, ... I have a feeling you will seriously regret that trade. ...
    (rec.games.pinball)
  • Re: AFM or POTC
    ... not a big Stern fan, so maybe I'm biased, but it feels like whenever I play ... know, If you owned pirates, would you trade it straight up for AFM? ... I own an AFM and POTC. ...
    (rec.games.pinball)