Re: Scroll use by low level ranger

Bradd W. Szonye wrote: 
Bradd W. Szonye wrote:

You missed the point: Your /reasoning/ is incorrect, because you
have, as usual, cited an irrelevant rule.



Some Guy wrote:

Put those goalposts back, Bradd!  I wrote "Spell trigger items don't
require caster level checks to use."  You wrote "Incorrect."  Hence,
you were claiming my *statement* was incorrect ....


Yes, because it was poor reasoning.

You're still lying. Not only was it not incorrect reasoning, you're changing the basis of your objection now. Would like me to demonstrate?

Although now that you mention it,
the statement itself was also incorrect, because of spell resistance.

What in the name of St. Baldwin are you talking about? Spell resistance never interferes with a creature's own spells, items, or abilities, and spell resistance on a target has nothing to do with making a check to USE the item. Good God, Bradd, you're digging your own grave now. You don't need any help from me!

Your claim was both incorrect on its own /and/ incorrect reasoning.

Prove it. You've been bare-faced wrong about the rules twice now in this thread. How much more embarassment can you stand?
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Scroll use by low level ranger
    ... Bradd! ... I wrote "Spell trigger items don't ... because it was poor reasoning. ... the statement itself was also incorrect, ...
    (rec.games.frp.dnd)
  • Re: 3.5 E Spear Warrior
    ... >> Incorrect. ... At the time the quote, no one else had done so. ... similar responses. ... Bradd W. Szonye ...
    (rec.games.frp.dnd)
  • Re: Some Guy, it is illegal for you to post here.
    ... Spell Resistance doesn't apply to spells you *CAST,* ... Bradd would do exactly what he's been doing--snip & pretend the parts he ... were claiming my *statement* was incorrect. ...
    (rec.games.frp.dnd)
  • Re: Some Guy, it is illegal for you to post here.
    ... First of all, Sir Screwsupalot, let me point out how right I was that Bradd would do exactly what he's been doing--snip & pretend the parts he left out didn't exist. ... I wrote "Spell trigger items don't require caster level checks to use." ... you were claiming my *statement* was incorrect. ... the statement itself was also incorrect, because of spell resistance. ...
    (rec.games.frp.dnd)
  • Re: Some Guy, it is illegal for you to post here.
    ... Bradd would do exactly what he's been doing--snip & pretend the parts he ... I wrote "Spell trigger items don't ... were claiming my *statement* was incorrect. ... the statement itself was also incorrect, because of spell resistance. ...
    (rec.games.frp.dnd)