Re: An interesting hand to play (Aug 29, 2008)



On Aug 29, 3:42 am, Ivan Popivanov <popi...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
A very strong field, red vs red, you end up in three diamonds after
(you are the dealer):

1D*  (2C)  3D*  All Pass

1D: precision, 2+D
3D: weakish

The lead is the CK:

Dummy
9 5
K 9 4
K Q J 9 7 3
7 4

You
A K 4 2
J 2
8 6 5
A T 9 5

You take the club king, and play a diamond to the king, west (your
left) plays the D10. You continue with the DQ, East takes the ace and
west pitches the C6. Now East shifts to the S8 you take the ace and
exit with a low club, west wins the CJ and east follows. Now West
exits with the SQ you take the ace ... and it's you. Here are the
cards played so far (the first card in each trick is marked with an
'*')

   West   North   East   South
1) *CK    C4        C3     CA
2) DT      DK       D2      *D6
3) C6     *DQ       DA     D5
4) S3      S5        *S8    SA
5) CJ      C7        C2     *C5
6) *SQ    S9        S6     SK

Two questions:

1. Would you have played the hand differently?
2. What now, most importantly - why? :)

Cheers,
Ivan

1. Yes. As Frances suggested, a heart play at trick 2 seemed to be a
better bet.

2. East is either 3532 or 4432.

If he's 3532, Charles' second line (eliminate spades and run the J of
hearts) is 100%.

If he's 4432 we have a 100% line of play by ruffing a spade high in
dummy, playing a trump back to our 8 and then throwing RHO in with the
last spade, pitching a heart.

East is down to nothing but hearts and must give us our 9th trick.

If West produces the last spade ruff in dummy and play hearts twice
from dummy. We'll still make it home in the unlikely event East holds
the AQ of hearts.

Assuming the opps. give standard remainder count, East's spade plays
seem to be more consistent with a holding of T876 rather than 876.
Also, once East plays the S8, West might have carded differently in
spades holding QJT3. 4432 is also a bit more likely than 3532
distribution.

So the line 2 (the spade end-play) seems mildly better than line 1
(eventually running the heart J).

Cheers.

Nick
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: A remarkable deal continued
    ... Then a spade is led from the table. ... Now declarer is stuck. ... And a diamond play is much better than a club after taking the trump ... establish hearts while he still has entries in dummy, ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: A remarkable deal continued
    ... Then a spade is led from the table. ... Now declarer is stuck. ... And a diamond play is much better than a club after taking the trump ... establish hearts while he still has entries in dummy, ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: A remarkable deal continued
    ... Then a spade is led from the table. ... Now declarer is stuck. ... And a diamond play is much better than a club after taking the trump ... establish hearts while he still has entries in dummy, ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: Win the match with Restricted Choice ??
    ... During the bidding E shows 4 hearts and W showing 4 spades ... two low diamonds and South discards a low spade. ... cash your top spades and as expected South discard a diamond on the ... You play the H7, ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: Win the match with Restricted Choice ??
    ... During the bidding E shows 4 hearts and W showing 4 spades ... dummy with a heart and take the club finesse which loses. ... two low diamonds and South discards a low spade. ... You play the H7, ...
    (rec.games.bridge)