Re: 2C "overcall": How do you rule?



On Nov 8, 11:44 am, Stu Goodgold <st...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

In my experience, most defenders against a 'may be short' club treat
it as a normal 1C opener, since opener has 3 clubs over 90% of the
time.

Also importantly, opener will have 4 clubs a significant percentage of
the time. I don't remember what this percentage is, but I think it's
60% or more...does someone else know the real percentage? For me,
that's the main reason not to play 2C as natural.

Things change when you open 1C on any minimum balanced hand, even on
hands with 4 or 5 diamonds; now I think the chance that opener has 2
clubs, or 3 poor ones, is significantly higher, which is why I
generally ask my partner to switch to 2C natural when we run into a
Polish club pair. I still don't know the exact percentage, though,
and I really have no idea whether playing this way is best.

-- Adam

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: defensive thinking
    ... diamonds and switch to a club. ... going away on clubs, so that points to leading clubs. ... A heart switch is very improbable from partner's perspective. ... It's possible for your side to have Axx opposite Kx and if partner ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: 2C "overcall": How do you rule?
    ... it as a normal 1C opener, since opener has 3 clubs over 90% of the ... Things change when you open 1C on any minimum balanced hand, ... Polish club pair. ... At high levels, quite a lot of pairs switch to 2C Natural, 2D Majors against ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: Thoughtful Bidding Problem
    ... the partner of the cuebidder will bid some ... Three clubs puts too much pressure on partner. ... and diamonds, from taking the ruffs in the wrong hand. ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: Matchpoints problem - Part 1.
    ... SAYC, new partner, no discussions ... Notrump for the opps is clearly a no go, since they rate to lose six club tricks (unless one of them has four clubs 8xxx or better). ... where not merely 4C, but 5C is for sure, as after the inevitable spade and diamond trick are given up, one round of trumps can be safely drawn, and the rest of the tricks are won via a cross-ruff. ... If this happens, you lead a heart, which partner wins via the free finesse; he then should cash HA and lead a third heart for you to ruff. ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: How many questions about an opening bid before its UI?
    ... Partner and I are both BLMs. ... LHO and I are both third generation ... Another possibility is that your hand suggests LHO has clubs. ... I can't see any reason in this case to think that is true. ...
    (rec.games.bridge)