Re: Flawed Analysis


"Bill Jacobs" <bill.jacobs@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:Xns9797A13317A2billjacobsozquestcom@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
"Anant Rege" <arege.@rogersdotcom> wrote in
news:1JidnV9ZHed4-LHZnZ2dnUVZ_tCdnZ2d@xxxxxxxx:

Following hand appeared in todays Globe and Mail, Toronto, Canada.

North

A J 10 x
K x
A 10 x x
A Q x

South

K Q x
Q x x
K Q 9 x
K J x

South opens 1 NT (15-17) and North jumps to 6 NT.
West leads a H 10, you play K, East takes A and continues. How do you
play?

<Skipping few lines>
<>
<>

<>

East

x x
A J x
J x x x
x x x x

West

x x x x x
10 x x x
x
x x x

The analysis by the columnist went as follows.

After taking H Q, if diamonds break 3-2, there are 12 tricks on top.
So you try to cater for a 4-1 break. Since 4 card D J can be finnessed
from either opponent, declarer should try to gather more information
about the opponent hands. When he cashes 3 clubs, both opponents
follow to all. When 4 spades are cashed, East discards on the third
spade. Now you know that West had 5 spades to start with, min. 2
hearts and 3 clubs so can not have 4 cards in diamonds. So you cash D
K followed by D A and finnesse East if they don't break.

Can you see the flaw in this reasoning assuming West is unlikely to
underlead an Ace after this bidding?

Anant




Sure.

Declarer should play low from dummy at trick 1.

If East wins ace, 12 tricks.

If East ducks, then cash the black suit winners. If you still don't know
who has 4 diamonds, cash KQ of diamonds. If East shows out, claim. If
West shows out, exit a heart to East's ace and claim.

Cheers ... Bill.

Yup. And you probably didn't even realize that there are 14 spades and 12
hearts. :-)

Actually you can cash D K and D Q at trick 2 and 3 and claim. But that is
just a show off.

Anant



.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Flawed Analysis
    ... After taking H Q, if diamonds break 3-2, there are 12 tricks on top. ... Now you know that West had 5 spades to start with, ... If East wins ace, 12 tricks. ... then cash the black suit winners. ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: Sudden jumps
    ... Although my bid doesn't promise an ace, ... partner has a right to play me for one. ... Plus, if he has something in spades, why is ... > And as your spades are very good, and you do have 2 diamonds shouldn't this ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: How to play this?
    ... Play the ace of diamonds and throw the last heart. ... Lead a small club back and duck the queen. ... After the ace of spades you ...
    (rec.games.bridge)
  • Re: Easy probability question (Bayes theorem)
    ... an ace of diamonds out of a deck of cards ... is it asking for the aces of spades and diamonds to be ... first card is one of those, that the second is the other one is 1/51. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: unusual squeeze (answer/description)
    ... All West knew at that point was that declarer started with 7 trumps ... Then he had to cash ... The ace of diamonds is better than a small ...
    (rec.games.bridge)