Re: photo eye NPN vs. PNP

On Sat, 15 Nov 2008 08:21:41 -0500, "Carl Boyd"
<carlsboyd@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:


"Karl Townsend" <karltownsend.NOT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:491ebb8d$0$67989$892e0abb@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
I'm about to purchase a photo eye. http://tinyurl.com/6bjmeb

What's the difference between PNP and NPN? I just want an eye that's NC
powered by 12VDC that uses very little power.


Karl



Karl

It has to do with the output transistor construction. From a practical
point of view, if your load has to be grounded get the PNP, if the load has
to be tied to the power supply, get the NPN.

To clarify a bit: an NPN sensor switches the negative wire; PNP
switches the positive. AN NPN sensor is a current sinking device; a
PNP is a current sourcing device.

Be careful when using the terms "sinking" and "sourcing" in the
context of industrial controls, especially PLCs. Some mfrs used (or
have in the past used) "sinking" to refer to a PLC input that's
compatible with a sinking sensor, even though the input itself is
sourcing current. Other mfrs use the convention that a sinking sensor
connects to a sourcing input. I'm not aware of any ambiguities in the
use of PNP/NPN. NPN devices are generally more flexible in systems
with mixed voltages.

(Fixed font)

PNP:
+V ---(sensor)-----------|
| |
|----(load)----| 0V

NPN:
+V |----(load)----|
| |
|-----------(sensor)--- 0V

--
Ned Simmons
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: capacitive loading an opamp
    ... Excess doping (a 5-layer PNP) would have lots of impurities, so much that I would think it would be fairly useless. ... The question, are monolithic PNP as reliable as NPN on a complementary process, I would expect NPN are given priority on process refinements, because they perform slightly better and deserve those refinements. ... But a much wider answer would have to ask in return, what circuit is it in? ... It's my recollection that NPNs are made with an N-well (the collector) embedded in a P-substrate, and putting two more junctions on top of that necessarily makes a four layer device. ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: capacitive loading an opamp
    ... Excess doping (a 5-layer PNP) ... it has more dislocations than substrate silicon. ... are monolithic PNP as reliable as NPN on a complementary ... biased (making the common collector region between the PNP and NPN ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: How to identify PNP or NPN device?
    ... > known to be a bipolar PNP or NPN device. ... The 2 terminals are emitter ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Why does this power supply use low-side regulation?
    ... one NPN pass transistor anyway (i.e., ... your big filter cap rather than the having a pass transistor inbetwen... ... Pnp power ... Wescott Design Services ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: DM74LS244
    ... >>the NPN, the degradation of the opto's current transfer ratio ... with a PNP, that'd be a pullup, wouldn't it? ... GND GND ... And the load, of course, I'd move to the collector, which would be on ...
    (sci.electronics.design)