Re: "Flash of Genius" movie

On Sun, 28 Sep 2008 03:30:39 GMT, BobH
<WanderingMetalHead.DUMP.SPAM@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:


My employer paid $500 or $1k and I never felt shorted during the
process, but 5 years later when the subpoena to defend the a patent that
had been sold to a bunch of litigous trolls showed up 4 days before
Christmas, I was way less than pleased. After spending a couple of days
preparing and giving deposition, I felt distinctly screwed on that $500
or $1k.

Why? The $500 or $1K was an "award" or honorarium for assigning
rights to said to your employer. Defending it is then his problem. If
he needs your help, he should pay for your time and services like he
does for any other time and services.

Filing patents for your employer is a lot like signing up for the
military in peacetime for their college benefits. You may get what you
expected, but you may wind up getting a completely different education,
at a time you did not expect.

I'm seeing more gimmewhine than professional here. Signing with the
military in peacetime or anytime conveys obligations as well as
benefits. Well duh! The military does not exist primarily to provide
college benefits. It exists to defend the nation against enemies
foreign and domestic. There is never a guarantee that there won't be
any enemies around during your service period. Pick yer pony, take
yer ride.

If your employer wants your professional services to help defend his
patent, fine. If he doesn't, that's his choice.

Part of being a professional is being ready to move at any time. The
alternative is becoming an indentured servant in exchange for an
illusion of security. Having to move can certaintly be very
inconvenient and expensive. In my case, clear willingness to do it
if and when necessary always made it unnecessary.

It would take singularly stupid management to piss off their most
prolific inventors, but there's no shortage of stupid management and
that does seem to be getting worse. My experience is dated, having
been retired for 9 years now.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: "Flash of Genius" movie
    ... Every patent I have disclosed to an employer came with the express language that you would help them or their assignee defend the patent. ... Filling in the patent disclosure carries obligations as well as the payoff. ...
    (rec.crafts.metalworking)
  • Re: anseemet the romantic sentimentalist NOT!!!!
    ... But when it is revealed to the employer and then condoned, ... the entire credibilty of the organization is negated. ... You seem to willfully misunderstand the nature of MusicWeb. ... defend himself on rmcr when afaik he's never posted anything here, ...
    (rec.music.classical.recordings)
  • Re: anseemet the romantic sentimentalist NOT!!!!
    ... But when it is revealed to the employer and then condoned, ... the entire credibilty of the organization is negated. ... You seem to willfully misunderstand the nature of MusicWeb. ... defend himself on rmcr when afaik he's never posted anything here, ...
    (rec.music.classical.recordings)
  • Re: Marcello predicts 500% perfomance improvement
    ... The simple truth is that most of us don't even know what we ... HP is my employer, and it is not in my interest to say bad ... >> Maybe so, but be truthful, would you be upset if Alpha was still being ... you can only expect them to work hard to defend ...
    (comp.os.vms)
  • Re: Under-Appreciated Gems of Scientific Epistemology
    ... > Reproducible empirical demonstration by despised and undeserving ... our patentable work for $1 - Well, ... agent of the employer, ...
    (sci.econ)