Re: Harbor Freight winch vs. McMaster winch, and wire rope

Just a thought, I use "blue" rope on my ATV winch. It's supposed to be stronger than the cable, and will not snap back if broken. I can also go around a small radius drum without effort. I used to use cable when using a snow plow on my ATV, but the cable could not handle the almost right angle bend from the fairlead to the plow and broke. I've used the rope for two years without breaking. The only negative is the price (expensive). Look at http://www.newircusers.com/store/rk2025_43984_Plow_Lift_Rope_Atv_Amsteel_Blue_Winch_Line.jsp for one source.

Dave



Ignoramus9168 wrote:
As I mentioned earlier, I installed a Harbor Freight "truck crane" on
my truck. When trying to lift a 300 lbs rotary table into my truck,
using the crane, the winch jammed. It jammed because somehow the drum
went off its axis by about 1-2 mm.

Its other problem is that the hub ot the Harbor Freight winch was very
thin (less than 1 inch, for a 1/4 inch cable). As a result, the cable
would not wind nicely around the drum and it was a mess causing some
kinks.

After this jamming, I briefly considered fixing the winch, but decided
against it.

Instead, I bought a McMaster winch 3644T53. I also bought a cover for
it (shown on same page 1388). The price was $28 + $7.

I did not fit existing holes on HF crane exactly, so I had to mill one hole bigger, about 2mm in one direction.

The result is much nicer -- it looks way better with a cover, and the
hub is 2 inches thick, so the wire rope wraps very nicely around the
hub without kinking.

That said, I am now considering replacing HF rope also, and would like
to know if "all wire rope is the same", or perhaps some wire rope is
more flexible than other kinds of wire rope. I have been reading
McMaster's description of various wire rope construction methods (6x37
etc) and it seems that this Harbor Freight wire rope is not
greatest. (which I sort of expected).

For those who would offer a snide remark such as "why did you buy this
crane if so many components are crap", I would answer that the crane
body does seem to be very sturdy, and a comparable brand name crane
would cost way above $1,000. I have never seen them sold, used.

Anyone has any experience? Would I gain anything from spending to buy
more expensive wire rope?

i
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Harbor Freight winch vs. McMaster winch, and wire rope
    ... It jammed because somehow the drum ... Its other problem is that the hub ot the Harbor Freight winch was very ... I did not fit existing holes on HF crane exactly, ... so the wire rope wraps very nicely around the ...
    (rec.crafts.metalworking)
  • Re: Harbor Freight winch vs. McMaster winch, and wire rope
    ... When trying to lift a 300 lbs rotary table into my truck, ... Its other problem is that the hub ot the Harbor Freight winch was very ... I did not fit existing holes on HF crane exactly, so I had to mill one hole bigger, about 2mm in one direction. ... so the wire rope wraps very nicely around the ...
    (rec.crafts.metalworking)
  • Re: Bungee at Long Myndd
    ... As for the recent Winch Launching debate, we did find that the woven ... rope which was easier to splice, ... A good winch driver is the best 'constant tension' device, ... breaks will be experienced at about 100 launches. ...
    (rec.aviation.soaring)
  • Re: Auto Tow Information
    ... way the Yahoo Winch design group did. ... 20 MPH on the return trip, and try to lay the rope ... tow release. ... then drive quickly back to the launch ...
    (rec.aviation.soaring)
  • Re: Winch launch clinic at Faribault, Minnesota
    ... Aborted launch. ... winch driver training, wind, so there a few may have been 1300ft. ... The rope used was 1/4" Amsteel II type (not clear which type, ... fid that was a chore to use and a plastic fid that just wouldn't work. ...
    (rec.aviation.soaring)