Re: Bird feeder that doesn't spill 1/2 the food on the ground?




<google_poster@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1151628123.217668.119140@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Thanks to everyone who replied to an earlier posting about getting a
variety of birds. I changed to nyjer seed and things are going great.
I'm also going to start feeding sunflower hearts.
BUT, both of my feeders spill food like crazy! Half of the seed - or
more - ends up on the ground.

For the nyjer I'm using a WoodLink Magnum Thistle Feeder. It's great
the way it gets covered with Finches - so I like the style, but the
ground is turning black under it.

For the more generic food - where I'm going to start feeding sunflower
hearts - I have a tube feeder, "Squirrel Be Gone Feeder" by Perky Pet.
When I was putting millet-based food in it, the house finches loved it
but spilled a lot.

Is this just the way that bird feeders work? Any ideas on alternate
designs?

Thanks,
Bob


Most of what you are seeing under the nyjer feeder is probably shells, not
seed. They do pile up thick, and I also thought they were seeds (and waste)
when I first saw it. Someone at Wild Birds Unlimited told me to look
closely, and I would probably see tiny shells. He was right! So, it is a
natural byproduct (the finches snap the shells to extract the seed inside),
and you need some way to dispose of it -- rake it up or attach a tray
underneath, which will then need to be frequently emptied.

MaryL


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: How often to fill the bird-feeder?
    ... just about empty so the seed isn't going bad in the bottom of the feeder. ... the birds have plenty to eat on the ground under the ... have a difficult time finding food so I do my best to help. ... flower seeds, all kinds of bugs, etc., so I'm not so picky about it. ...
    (rec.birds)
  • Re: Bullfinches
    ... feeder, unlike the other finches. ... The birds do not detect any difference in quality. ... day visitors and sit and chew the seeds for ages - usually come as ... Oh and the Goldfinches have still yet to come! ...
    (uk.rec.birdwatching)
  • Re: Feeding wild birds
    ... the birds will pass it buy to get to just about anything else. ... isn't a rotting pile of unopened and sprouting seeds to be shoveled ... put in my globe Cling-a-Wing feeder for nuthatches and chickadees. ... House Sparrow flock to it. ...
    (rec.birds)
  • Re: Feeding wild birds
    ... the birds will pass it buy to get to just about anything else. ... isn't a rotting pile of unopened and sprouting seeds to be shoveled ... They eat them 100% because of that?! ... put in my globe Cling-a-Wing feeder for nuthatches and chickadees. ...
    (rec.birds)
  • Re: Bird feeder that doesnt spill 1/2 the food on the ground?
    ... For the nyjer I'm using a WoodLink Magnum Thistle Feeder. ... in the bottom, the seeds it catches will fall through the holes, or if it ... bowls under the tube-type thistle and bosfs feeders with success, ... away from your ground-feeding birds, depending on how much you value them... ...
    (rec.birds)