Re: Interesting Take on Climate Change Argument



hank alrich wrote:

Eeyore <rabbitsfriendsandrelations@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

It's a shame that the IPCC haven't been very scientific themselves. That's
largely what this is about.

Demonstrate. Show your chops.

Summary

Accurate chemical CO2 gas analyses of air over 180 years show a different trend
compared
to the literature of IPCC climate change actually published. From 1829 the
concentration
of carbon dioxide of air in the northern hemisphere fell down from a value of
e.g. 400 ppm
up to 1900 to less than 300 ppm rising till 1942 to more than 400 ppm. After
that maximum
it fell down to e.g. 350 ppm and rose again till today, 2006 to 380 ppm.
Accurate
measurements had been done amongst others by de Saussure 1826,
Pettenkofer/v.Gilm
1857, Schulze 1864/71, Farsky 1874, Uffelmann 1886, Letts und Blake 1897, Krogh
and
Haldane 1904, Benedict 1912, Lundegardh 1920, van Slyke 1929, Dürst and Kreutz
1934
alternatively 1940, Misra 1942 or Scholander 1946 with measuring instruments
through
which from 1857 (Pettenkofer) an accuracy of +/-0,0006 Vol% to under +/-0,0003
Vol%
=~3 ppm (Lundegardh 1926) was achieved. These pioneers of chemistry, biology,
botany,
medicine and physiology constituted the modern knowledge of metabolism,
nutrition
science, biochemistry and ecology. Modern climatology ignored their work till
today even
though it is the basis of all textbooks of the mentioned faculties and was
honoured with
several Nobel prizes. In total over 90 000 measurements within nearly every year
since 180
year gave the following results:

1. There is no constant exponential rising CO2-concentration since preindustrial
times but a
variing CO2-content of air following the climate. E.G. around 1940 there was a
maximum of CO2 of at least 420 ppm, before 1875 there was also a maximum.

2. Historical air analysis by chemical means do not prove a preindustrial CO2-
concentration of 285 ppm (IPCC),as modern climatology postulates. In contrast
the
average in the 19th century in northern hemisphere is 321 ppm and in the 20th
century 338
ppm.

3. Todays CO2 value of. 380 ppm, which is considered as threatening has been
known
several times in the last 200 years, in the 20 th century around 1942 and before
1870 in
the 19th century. The maximum CO2-concentration in the 20th century roses to
over 420
pmm in 1942.

4. Accurate measurements of CO2 air gas contents had been done from 1857 by
chemical
methods with a systematical error of maximal 3%. These results were ignored
reconstructing the CO2 concentration of air in modern warm period.

5. Callendar and Keeling were the most important founders of the modern
greenhouse
theory (IPCC) beside Arrhenius. Literature research confirmed that they ignored
a big
part of available technical papars and selected only a few values to get a
validation of
their hypothesis of fuel burning induced rise of CO2 in air. Furthermore these
authors
discussed and reproduced the few selected historic results by chemical methods
in a
faulty way and propagated an unfounded view of the quality of these methods,
without
having dealt with its chemical basis.

6. To reconstruct the modern CO2 concentration of air icecores from Antarctica
had been
used. The presented reconstructions are obviously not accurate enough to show
the
several variations of carbon dioxide in northern hemisphere.

Ernst-Georg Beck's paper 180 Years accurate CO2 Gas analysis of Air by Chemical
Methods

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: OT - Hansen acknowledges solar forcing
    ... Has CO2 increased or is this just natural variation? ... Check out the story that CO2 measurements from the Wisconsin Tower ... CO2 has been measured at Mauna Loa Observatory Hawaii since 1959. ... The "globally distributed network of air ...
    (sci.electronics.design)
  • Re: Oxygen percent in a room
    ... I live in a recently built house that is one of these "super-insulated" ... The measured co2 in my living area ranges from approximately 500 ppm to ... heat by running the forced air intake fans less. ... from knowing the co2 concentration (and humidity percent ...
    (sci.chem)
  • Re: How long will a given supply of air last?
    ... there are 3-4 semi-independent components of air recycling. ... I never realised that o2 generation and CO2 removal were seperate ... >Also, if you are going for realism, one would expect such a station to have backup systems. ... Do these oxygen candles burn like flares, ...
    (sci.space.science)
  • Re: Culling by suffocation
    ... Air about 28 ... Its certainly very easy to have a stable layer of CO2 sitting below the ... takes a random walk around the available space, just does each molecule ...
    (uk.business.agriculture)
  • Re: More proof that global warming is a hoax ...
    ... And what happened between then and now hasn't a damned thing to do with CO2. ... The real dangers is from pollution with dirty devices that pump real pollutants into the air that do affect life. ... when rational argument fails, invent a conspiracy - never mind that the money the energy industry pours into political coffers makes it far more likely that politicians would oppose the idea of monkeying around with their sources of revenue. ... the burden of proof (when you're disputing the consensus of scientists far more qualified to form opinions in this area than you are) is on you. ...
    (comp.os.vms)