MOTU vs. RME, Sound Devices portable interface

I'm looking for an excellent portable interface to use with my Mac
Powerbook G4 (1500 Mhz). I'm running Digital Performer 5 and OS
10.4.8. Which do you recommend?

I'm looking at:

MOTU Ultralite
RME Fireface 400
Sound Devices USB pre 1.5

Questions:
-I've read in previous posts about lots of problems with the RME and
Mac. Are these resolved?

- I've read that the D/A on the Sound Devices glitches upon playback.
Is that still a problem?

- Is there any major difference in the latency problems with these
different models?

- When I next upgrade my Powerbook will there be any issues with any
of these pieces?

- Do the new MOTU mic pre's compete at all with the RME or SD? How
about the A/D?

- I rarely hear anybody talking about the Sound Devices. How is the
software? Is there good monitoring? I assume the mic pre's are first
rate.

- Is there any advantage to sticking with MOTU if I'm using DP?

Use: I'm sure you'll ask what I'm doing with this. I do soundtrack
work. I have an elaborate studio (albeit somewhat outdated) with
video sync and 24 Channels of A/D, built on an old G4 450 (running
OS9) and a Motu 2408. I'm looking for an excellent portable system
that I can use while on the road, or for location recording. 2 - 4
mics is fine (although more inputs could be useful on occasion).
Although I don't necessarily plan to mix the two systems (portable and
studio), they do need to be compatible so that I can move projects
from one to the other.

I know that the OS 9 vs. OS10 issue is going to be a pain. Someday
soon I'm going to have to invest in a G5 and willl probably upgrade
much of the other equipment at the same time (but I can't afford it
now). the RME stuff does seem to be a step up from my MOTU system, so
that might be the way I go when I upgrade the studio - Although I've
been very happy with MOTU for many years.

Thanks,
Ken Winokur / Alloy Orchestra

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: MOTU vs. RME, Sound Devices portable interface
    ... concert tours. ... I get playback, but it has never shown up in the DP ... they are essentially a Mac oriented company. ... I'd have every confidence in a MOTU interface with any future Mac ...
    (rec.audio.pro)
  • Re: MOTU Traveler review
    ... Those who want to use the Traveler with the Mac should pay no attention to ... I've been using a Motu 1296 for maybe 5 years now. ... the PCI card, ... my PCI based interface has worked very well over the years on ...
    (rec.audio.pro)
  • Re: RME Fireface 400 and Mac
    ... Everythining I've heard about the MOTU Traveler,http://www.motu.com/products/motuaudio/traveler, is a rave. ... powered by the FireWire interface of a Mac. ... MOTU's site to compare the tech specs but RME has been making ...
    (rec.audio.pro)
  • Re: MOTU Traveler review
    ... The use of MOTU hardware with PCs ... while using the gear with Mac computers ... The Motu PCI based stuff generally works quite well on the Windows platform, ... I would never in my wildest dreams consider buying a Motu F/Wire interface ...
    (rec.audio.pro)
  • Noise Leaking Thru USB from Mac Powerbook with MOTU Midi Express XT
    ... MOTU then goes into a EMU tone generator via MIDI I/O; ... I also have the Powerbook firewire to a Yamaha O2R. ... I check the USB connection between O2R and ...
    (comp.music.midi)