Re: ipod vs cd



"ck19" <ck19bla@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1157610737.175475.197420@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

if i run a ipod recording through my stereo system will
the sound quality be less than a pre-recorded cd of the
same song?

Not necessarily.

can you easily tell the difference?

Too many variables to make a relevant comment. As others have pointed out,
the origional model of Ipod is no longer just one digital audio player, but
a family of players that have changed significantly under the covers.

Then, there are all those different models of iPod.

Here are some boundary examples:

(1) It is possible to load an iPod with a bit-perfect copy of any track on a
CD, and then unload that track back to another CD. If you do everything
right, the origional pre-iPod version and the post-iPod version are
mathematically indistingushable. Therefore under ideal conditions, they must
sound the same.

(2) If you have a really crappy CD player and an audio system that is
otherwise highly excellent, playing the track mentioned in the prevous
example from an iPod through that audio system might sound better than
playing the same track off the origional CD on the crappy CD player.

(3) If you have a reasonably good CD player and audio system, and you match
levels and time-synch the playback from the CD player and the iPod, then you
probably won't easily notice any difference.

(4) Anybody who says that playback from an iPod always sounds like crap is
wrong, and anybody who says that playback from an iPod always sounds
superior is wrong.



.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Mustang / iPod and sound
    ... > Have you taken a look at the Crutchfield www.crutchfield.com catalog? ... I use one for my portable DVD/CD player to channel ... The transmit the sound source over a given FM frequency. ... >>sound/cassette adpaters to play my music from the iPod. ...
    (rec.autos.makers.ford.mustang)
  • Re: (NBC) ipod or mp3 player?
    ... since this question was originally about ipod vs others: ... I found that other players (such as the creative I finally bought) had ... the player and chose not to pay for the little apple on the player. ... I chose the slightly thicker creative with better sound and a cheaper price, ...
    (rec.music.artists.springsteen)
  • Re: OT: Now youve done it
    ... I also got the Griffin RoadTrip, which is a neat little FM transmitter that works for all iPods--and the sound is better than my old CD player through the cassette adapter. ... Does anyone have experience with the speakers? ... I did see the speakers at Costco, but not the Ipod. ...
    (sci.med.transcription)
  • Re: Mustang / iPod and sound
    ... Have you taken a look at the Crutchfield www.crutchfield.com catalog? ... I use one for my portable DVD/CD player to channel ... The transmit the sound source over a given FM frequency. ... >sound/cassette adpaters to play my music from the iPod. ...
    (rec.autos.makers.ford.mustang)
  • Code Addendum 01 - gforth: OpenGL Graphics Lesson 21
    ... \ to implement the sound capability, ... player object% nip 0 fill ... hourglass object% nip 0 fill ... \ Is fine pos on x axis lower than intended pos? ...
    (comp.lang.forth)