Re: Stereophile


Clyde Slick wrote:
> >
> > George applied his criterion to the letters.
> > I chose to apply that same criterion to the staff writers
> > and found similar results.
> > They are not accorded the courtesy of having their words
> > presented without editing, nor are they presumed to be experts
> > in their field by virtue of their credentials.
> > If you feel the criterion is flawed in the application to
> > staff writers then it must be similarly flawed for letters.
> > So... is your complaint with the criterion or with the
> > results when applied to staff writers?
> >
> > ScottW
>
>
> Come on Scott, virtually all magazines (note, this is
> not about scientific journals) edit their writers.

So do comic books.

> And it is you who presume them to not be experts.

I don't presume anything. I certainly don't presume them to be
experts by virtue of their position of writer.

> Nowhere has it been presented that the editor makes the same presumptions.

Not presuming them to not be experts does not lead to presuming them
to be experts. What's your point?

ScottW

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Stereophile
    ... >>> George applied his criterion to the letters. ... >>> staff writers then it must be similarly flawed for letters. ... >> And it is you who presume them to not be experts. ...
    (rec.audio.opinion)
  • Re: Stereophile
    ... Scott; not the staff writers. ... > George applied his criterion to the letters. ...
    (rec.audio.opinion)
  • Re: Stereophile
    ... >> George applied his criterion to the letters. ... >> staff writers then it must be similarly flawed for letters. ... > There's a possible complaint with your logic. ...
    (rec.audio.opinion)
  • Re: Stereophile
    ... >>> George applied his criterion to the letters. ... >>> staff writers then it must be similarly flawed for letters. ... >> There's a possible complaint with your logic. ...
    (rec.audio.opinion)
  • Re: Stereophile
    ... >>> George created the criteria for determining expertise. ... Scott; not the staff writers. ... > George applied his criterion to the letters. ... And it is you who presume them to not be experts. ...
    (rec.audio.opinion)