Re: Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- From: "FirstHit" <FirstHit@xxxxxxx>
- Date: 30 Jan 2006 14:07:35 -0800
Jennifer Kalman wrote:
> Nicola <nicolabaltimore@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
> : ravelation wrote:
>
> : > How do you see John Abbott's guilt?
>
> : It seems like it was premeditated to me. He got the gun weeks before
> : and got in his car and drove to the 'bad' side of town. He went there
> : to kill Tom.
>
> I don't think that he got the gun to kill tom. He got the gun to protect
> his family if tom showed up.
>
> Also, I don't think he took his gun planning to kill tom that night. Yes
> he did point it at him. But I don't think anyone can prove that he was
> going to kill tom. Tom lept forward and john was saying no the whole
> time.
>
> I'm just curious who will go to trial, ashley or john?
>
> I really can't imagine that a jury would convict john. He is such a good
> man, who was trying to protect his family from a violent creep. Plus
> since tom lept forward at him and made the gun go off, you can't really
> prove what john's intent was or what would have happened.
I agree with much of what you say. You should never point a gun at
someone though unless you expect to use it. I think Tom's response was
the wrong one, but sometimes people panic when a gun is pointed at
them. Bottom line: I don't think John is guilty of murder, but I do
think he is guilty of playing a role in Tom's homicide. That doesn't
mean he'll be convicted though.
FirstHit
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- From: Jennifer Kalman
- Re: Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- References:
- Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- From: ravelation
- Re: Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- From: Nicola
- Re: Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- From: Jennifer Kalman
- Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- Prev by Date: GL: Soap Opera Encyclopedia question
- Next by Date: Re: ATWT: Jack and Nick - Another Brokeback Mountain waiting to happen . . . . . . . . .
- Previous by thread: Re: Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- Next by thread: Re: Y&R- Is John Guilty?
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
