Re: JMS: Re: Babylon 5 Universe Novels?

In article <7d6dnTCfnO18Y8veRVn-sQ@xxxxxxxxxxx>, Carl says...
>
>
><jmsatb5@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
>news:1129763371.988536.28150@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>>
>> As a producer, my revenue from the DVDs is tied to the overall profit
>> of the show, which is still showing $50 million in the red (thanks to
>> creative accounting), so I get zero off the sales of the DVDs as a
>> producer.
>>
>> As a small potted plant, I get even less.
>
>So the accountants (who are apparently fiction writers in their own right)
>make
>money on the DVDs and you don't.

Almost to add insult to injury, the costs of those accountants are (or were)
being charged against the show, too, I'm afraid.

Actually, as an accountant, I can tell you that it's perfectly reasonable and
necessary for expenses incurred by the studio overall to be spread amongst the
individual shows. What I don't get, because I've never seen a set of books for
a studio, is how it can be so everlasting and ongoing (if it actually is).

>After so many years of this I would have thought that the various guilds and
>unions would have found away to make the process more honest.

I'm not sure that it is dishonest, no matter how much I might wish JMS were
getting a cut of the money brought in by the DVDs and other items. It's not
even 'creative accounting' but standard business practice.

Put it this way...JMS has said that B5 cost about $110 million to make. That's
what the *budget* was, though, the controllable expenses, not what it actually
cost. Even though the B5 soundstages weren't on the WB lot, it's still only
fair and reasonable that, being a WB production, a portion of the costs of
running WB should be charged against the show as overhead. That includes such
items as security, storage, office personnel, all those high-paid execs and
*many* other charges from striping the parking lot to loan interest payments to
taxes to paper clips (and yes, even that set burning down in Latvia). *All* of
those charges would need to be distributed among the shows in production because
without the structure of the studio, no shows would get made. Chances are,
that's where the huge deficit occurred starting the first day B5 went into
production.

That's why the difference between a show 'making money each year' by bringing in
more in advertising than the budgeted expenses to make the show can be hugely
different from what shows up on a profit and loss statement.

What I don't know is for how long things can be directly charged against a show
no longer in production. If there are still 'overhead' items being charged
against the show, I'd be kind of surprised. Items such as production costs of
the DVDs would be about all I'd expect any longer with the possible exception of
advertising and sales items. I wouldn't know that without seeing a statement,
if then, since I'm not that familiar with the industry.

Hopefully if any of this contradicts what JMS has seen on his statements, he'll
let us know. At any rate, this concludes the 'more than anybody *ever* wanted
to know about Accounting' portion of tonight's entertainment. ;-)

Jan


--
Here, gathered together in common cause
We agree to recognize this singular truth
and this singular rule:
That we must be kind to one another.
G'Kar (J. Michael Straczynski)

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Just in Time levelling
    ... versions thereof, Work in Process accounting, job costing, invoicing, links ... The software dosen't exist becasue it wouldn't sell, because the scheduling idea for a vast ... majority of the world is cost accounting based, ... has an elaborate Production ...
    (microsoft.public.project)
  • Re: Just in Time levelling
    ... you set the tasks to start as late as possible, it just does not resource ... not the production managers view of the ... The software dosen't exist becasue it wouldn't sell, because the scheduling idea for a vast ... majority of the world is cost accounting based, ...
    (microsoft.public.project)
  • Re: Just in Time levelling
    ... you set the tasks to start as late as possible, it just does not resource ... not the production managers view of the ... The software dosen't exist becasue it wouldn't sell, because the scheduling idea for a vast ... majority of the world is cost accounting based, ...
    (microsoft.public.project)
  • Re: Just in Time levelling
    ... versions thereof, Work in Process accounting, job costing, invoicing, links ... The software dosen't exist becasue it wouldn't sell, because the scheduling idea for a vast ... majority of the world is cost accounting based, ... has an elaborate Production ...
    (microsoft.public.project)
  • Re: B5: TLT - Official Warner Bros. Press release
    ... Above and Beyond DVDs came out? ... IIRC, they were even produced by different networks (SAAB was a Fox production, B5 a WB production). ... I suppose it's also possible the DVDs for both shows were done by the same company, or someone at Fox was surfing the web for B5 stuff on company time and accidentally saved it to the fileserver, and then some OTHER guy is like "Oooh, cool spacestation, this will look good on the DVD!" ... "Sola bona lingua est mortua lingua" ...
    (rec.arts.sf.tv.babylon5.moderated)