Re: Padme and ROTJ Luke and Leia

Anybody, you magnificent ***. I read your post:
> In article <42bc1141$0$35162$892e7fe2@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
> "C'Pi" <askme@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>
>> Anybody, you magnificent ***. I read your post:
>>> In article <FY-dnbTlIcD16ibfRVn-rw@xxxxxxx>, Bill Anderson
>>> <billanderson601@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
>>>
>>>> John wrote:
>>>>> .
>>>>> I have another problem with what they did with Padme at the end. I
>>>>> remember from Return of the Jedi when Luke asks Leia about her
>>>>> mother. Leia has "Feelings of sadness" who is she referring to if
>>>>> Padme is dead before Leia becomes old enough to be aware...
>>>>>
>>>>
>>>> Somebody needs to submit the True Answer to this one for inclusion
>>>> in the RASSM FAQ.
>>>>
>>>> So what is the True Answer? I'll give it a shot:
>>>>
>>>> Leia was so strong in the Force that she remembered her own birth
>>>> and who was in the delivery room. The Force gave infant Leia the
>>>> ability to recognize physical beauty in her own mother, and to
>>>> sense her sad feelings. Wait, that's absurd.
>>>
>>> It's only "absurd" to people with no brains (and those who twist the
>>> wording to make it seem "absurd").
>>>
>>> Leia doesn't REMEMBER anything at all. During her dreams and quiet
>>> times she has seen the past through her unknown / untrained Force
>>> abilities and THOUGHT she was remembering events she had witnessed.
>>> Yoda himself says that through the Force you will see the past and
>>> the future.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>> (Furthermore, if Leia really did remember Padme, why didn't Luke
>>>> remember too?
>>>
>>> Luke doesn't "remember" because, again as Yoda says, he's always
>>> concentrating on the future and doesn't take time to stop and smell
>>> the poo-doo.
>>>
>>> Plus girls usually have a stronger connection to their mothers than
>>> boys do.
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>> This is a solution makes sense and fits with what we already know.
>>
>> But it's still stupid.
>
> Only to those who are already terminally stupid themselves. :-\
>
> It fits with everything we know and makes perfect sense.

But it's still stupid.
--
C'Pi
"It's because of men like you that all must be destroyed."


.

Loading