Re: Tracking

Mark L. Fergerson wrote:

I keep thinking about the interface between the volume of the Alcubierre bubble and ordinary spacetime. Light travels at c inside the bubble, _and_ outside it, but what happens at the interface?

Remember that locally (in the vicinity of a point), general relativity decays to special relativity. It's only global spacetime curvature that can result in weird situations like this. That's why things like inflation, which don't seem like they'd make logical sense, are possible in general relativity even though they'd obviously result in objects moving faster than light relatively to each other if one could simply measure their separation speeds. Because of this global curvature, it makes measuring speeds at a distance essentially meaningless. This is, for instance, why you get the weird behavior you're probably familiar with near horizons where distant observers "see" an infalling object hover near the horizon, but an actual observer falling in hits the singularity in finite proper time.

The same thing happens here. At the interface, things are still locally special relativistic. It just seems weird when you look at it globally. (And "globally" by itself doesn't make unique sense because they're still subject to relativity, and what they see depends on their speed.)

So the answer is that light still travels at c at the interface. It _always_ travels at c.

Yep, but we live in STL-spacetime, and nobody knows what things would look like from FTL-spacetime (assuming any such thing exists)

But without a coherent theory this devolves into speculation. But you're talking about an Alcubierre drive. That _is_ something modeled by general relativity. Now, of course, it may well be unphysical -- and probably is -- but general relativity will tell you how it behaves.

Sure, you can handwave something entirely new, but when you do that, you're left with pure speculation with no substance. Which is fine if you're handwaving for a story, I suppose, but beyond that it's not going to really go anywhere -- especially when you're talking about things that completely violate our conception of how the Universe works, such as luxons travelling at speeds other than c. At that point the game is up and the rules are so badly broken that there are no rules left.

--
Erik Max Francis && max@xxxxxxxxxxx && http://www.alcyone.com/max/
San Jose, CA, USA && 37 20 N 121 53 W && AIM erikmaxfrancis
The color is red / Under my shoe
-- Neneh Cherry
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: We have to respect the limits of human knowledge!
    ... but also about physics. ... The theory of general relativity is nothing to do with the speed of ... of the spacecraft have reached infinity. ... matter into speeds approaching the relativistic speeds region. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Misc Questions
    ... that you don't understand general relativity. ... Yes, speeds are relative. ... the galaxies are not plowing through space-time at anything ...
    (sci.astro.amateur)