Re: how to combat piracy in the dvd market



On 24 Jul 2005 21:43:41 GMT, "Bill Turner" <noway@xxxxxxxxx> Gave us:

>Jeff Rife wrote:
>
>> A disk that had no purpose other than to protect DVDs could easily be
>> made uncopyable because it could easily be made in such a way that
>> nothing could read it other than the special slot in the DVD player,
>> and, even if you could, nothing could write a disk like that because
>> nobody would manufacture blank media of that size/type.
>_________________________________________________
>
>If a disk can be played, it can be copied. If there were no identical
>blanks made, a different kind could be used.
>
>You underestimate the dedication and persistence of the hackers.

You are incorrect. What he mentions is a NON-standard disc form
factor that would have features such as a smaller hub opening or zone
sectored recording method. If there were no commercially available
readers, and the DVD slit opening drive was proprietary, you would
NEVER "read" the disc. Only players would.

A small mag strip device like the grocery store use could work. It
IS quite doable, and could be made quite cost and time prohibitive to
actually hack, and could also be made to detect such hacks and shut
off a player completely, requiring a service jaunt. Such an event
would be so costly to a consumer they they would never place a hacked
disc in their player again, let alone the "known thieves" list they
would be incorporated into.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Basic advice about making HD DVDs? (further opinions)
    ... They look OK when played with a normal DVD player on my widescreen HD ... Assuming I can eventually get an AVCHD disc burnt, am I right that I can only ... play this to my TV via a Blu-Ray player? ...
    (rec.video.desktop)
  • Re: Blu-Ray or HD, whos gonna win the format war
    ... now it's looking more and more like Blu-Ray film media sales are ... Joe public only really got to grips with DVD and widescreen CRT TV's a few ... shell out another thousand for a Blu-ray player... ... counting a PC) in different rooms and it is usually expected that a disc can ...
    (uk.media.dvd)
  • Re: Help with burning DVD-Audio
    ... look like typical video DVD files - a VIDEO_TS folder with VOB files. ... majority of DVD players on the market today don't support DVD-Audio. ... frequently used to create a disc that can be played back on any DVD ... If you don't have a player capable of playing back DVD-Audio discs you ...
    (rec.music.gdead)
  • Re: iDVD burned disk doesnt play?
    ... When I put it into the drive on my computer, DVD Player doesn't ... Player to play it, manually, so to speak. ... burning a disk directly from the VIDEO_TS folder? ...
    (comp.sys.mac.apps)
  • Re: DVD R/RW+- Drive not recognized by some software
    ... I may not have been clear in my intial post, but I am using DVD RW+ discs, ... improperly formatted disc. ... format and the recorder wont recognize the discs at all. ... Why do you wish to format the disk using a PC based utility? ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)