Re: Silence in the Library (possible spoilers [was Re: Silence in the Library (no spoilers)]


"Rob" <monst.oorzudo@xxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:6Jh0k.881898$us.685008@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
On Sat, 31 May 2008 20:18:30 +0100, Luke Curtis wrote:

if Ep2 lives up to episode 1 then we have a serious contender for best
Dr Who story ever.

Steady on!

Definately the best of the season so far. If eps 2 is as good it`ll
certainly be in the top 5 of new Who...and most of the rest would be
Moffat`s. I find it hard to rate episodes on a grander scale ( ie
BEST.EPISODE.EVER rants!) until sometime afterwards.

Where do I begin, the atmospherics were brilliant with incredible use of
light and shadow, beautiful set design, some truly chilling moments
(particularly right at the end of the episode) and good performances
from all the actors, even the PA managed to come over sympathetically
IMHO. The Music deserves special mention - it heightened the atmosphere
to a huge extent.

It was a good episode, yes. I keep wondering (or perhaps wishing) if that
woman is Romana in disguise, but I imagine that's just fanwank :-)

Seems to me she`s just some sort of future flame of the Doctor. He did keep
looking at her as if he wasn`t entirely happy about what she may represent
though. Perhaps Moffat plans to re-use her in a future story where more will
come clear?

I think it`s pretty clear Donna will snuff it at the end of the series from
what was said tonight.

I must admit I'm enjoying this season quite a lot.

Me too...there`s been quite a lot of negativity around S4 in here but I
think it`s been fine. The first episode was throwaway and the Doctor`s
Daughter was a bit iffy but other than that...good stuff.

Having said that, I
enjoyed last season until the final two episodes...

Am I the only one in here that enjoyed the finale of last season??




.

Relevant Pages