Re: Creativity vs. Control



Larry Gantman wrote:

<trish_connery@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1130363408.117348.193180@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Not saying
I like or enjoy it (although surprisingly, there can be moments), just
saying that perhaps I'll sigh, shrug, and then make the best of it.


As Mr. Jay suggested in another post, what if the dancer wants to win, thinks you're inferior, and feels the need to control you so that you don't make any mistakes that would detract from his chances of winning?

Ripley: These men are trained professionals. Newt: It won't make any difference.

A J&J is a crapshoot. I'm still struggling to put this into practice myself, but you just have to learn to accept who you've drawn and do the best you can with that person in a dance. Trying to push someone to the limits of what they can do is more likely to have the opposite of the desired effect. But the adrenaline rush one sometimes gets in competition is not particularly conducive to clear thinking.

There's a lot of followers with whom I fall into a pattern-oriented mode, and there's a handful of followers that just focus my attention and with whom I play a lot more with as a result. It's not what they look like, it's something in their connection, their playfulness, and what they bring to the dance; I hope I can figure out how they manage it and reproduce it from the leader's side someday. I try to have at least one dance with each of them each evening when I see them at a convention. I would ask more often but I would be too tempted to monopolize them (giving their husbands the wrong idea :-)).

Isn't
this a possible sign of inferiority in the leader, in that he doesn't trust
that he can invite you to participate without making mistakes, although
you're an excellent performer in your own right?  Perhaps this leader is
hoping for the perfect partner he'll never find, so he'll always feel the
need to restrict and control, rather than facilitating dances to remember.
:^(
Perhaps, or it could be a sign of a) poor J&J skills or b) too much adrenaline

So you agree with those who say that a WCS JnJ is a spontaneous street dance
and that musical interpretation is key, instead of believing that practiced
routines and choreography should win the day.
Unless you've got full choreography ready and memorized for hundreds of songs, choreography won't look as appropriate for a phrase as someone who learns to interpret the music like the all-stars and champions do. That said, more than a few all-star leaders got there by having some complicated "signature" moves that they placed in musically appropriate sections of the songs selected for a final. However, I think generally you're better off spending practice time polishing basics that you'll use throughout the whole song as opposed to a special move you'll use for less than a phrase.

P-A
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Band frustration
    ... My singer has become practically an extra member in the band for a long time ... a festival visit and threepractice sessions with his other ... getting nowhere in new songs either, because we have a bunch of new songs we ... the singer is what makes the band work. ...
    (alt.guitar)
  • Re: Girls
    ... played songs they had written. ... still trying to figure out how to grow my private practice. ... the final step (sitting for the exam). ... that court-ordered clients are not allowed to go thru their insurance... ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.acoustic)
  • Re: Girls
    ... Songs I like, songs I do well, songs that are perfect for my style. ... Preference, of course, is to build up the practice and continue working for myself if I can. ... I haven't sat for an exam in probably 25 years) to take the final step. ... It is my understanding that court-ordered clients are not allowed to go thru their insurance... ...
    (rec.music.makers.guitar.acoustic)
  • Re: Phoenix 2006
    ... Comments about the Masters competition -- IMHO the Masters music was ... strive to incorporate into the dance. ... submit there were 2 songs, MAYBE 3 songs, that were clearly "better" than ...
    (rec.arts.dance)
  • Re: The Tritone in The Middle Ages
    ... play chords, since players had five fingers on the plucking hand. ... there is fairly good evidence that the chordal practice developed ... late Renaissance -- while most earlier dance music appears in our ... performing the music from a lead sheet. ...
    (soc.history.medieval)