Re: Ich gone; now fungus?

Altum wrote:
FishNoob wrote:

In article <gR1Nf.61675$PL5.59140@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>, pt.altum@xxxxxxxxx says...

Is it mostly your mollies getting sick? Your water may be too soft for them. Mollies seem to like either hard or slightly salty water. Plants will tolerate 1 tsp/5 gallons of salt (0.02%) and sometimes even that much helps mollies stay well.



The mollies are where we notice the ich and the fungus, since most of them are black, but there are also danios and neon tetras in the tank, and I assume they are also affected - and not easily treated with salt. Yes, the water is soft; I wonder if that's part of the problem. What could I do about that?


If you don't see spots on the danios and tetras, don't assume they're affected. Many fish become immune to ich after they've been exposed to it once. Mollies in soft water are particularly susceptible to parasites like ich and velvet and don't seem to develop immunity as easily.

Putting the mollies in salted quarantine serves another purpose. If your other fish are immune, any parasites in the main tank will die off in a couple of weeks while the mollies are out of the tank. You could add a formalin remedy to the main tank if you're concerned but I think you'll only stress the fish.

As I said above, I think a bit of aquarium salt will help your mollies stay well. Some people also copper as a preventative, but you can't keep snails or shrimp very easily. "Shimmy blocks" contain gypsum to harden the water and copper. IIRC, Molly Bright is also a copper preparation with a bit of salt. Be careful with the copper - it's hard on tetras and more toxic in water with low kH.

I wish I had soft water - I've got good molly water here but my favorite dwarf cichlids and cardinals hate it. You might consider platies if you want more livebearers. They are more tolerant of soft water than mollies.


I think it was NetMax who once said that with Mollies it is more likely that the offspring will be hardier than the original parents...this has been borne out in the tank where we have Mollies - the parents died within 6 months but the now fully grown fry that we kept (4 of them) are over a year old now...

I'd go with the QT the Mollies,salt and treat the ich there...I have added salt with Neons but am not entirely convinced whether it was the ich or the salt that killed them off...don't know anything about Danios...but I have seen other fish in my tank appearing to be immune to ich even when the Clowns in my case were covered in it...

Gill
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: HELP!!! its ICK
    ... now you have Ich attacking your Mollies. ... I ask because mollies need salt in their water. ... Why they're sold as a freshwater fish is beyond me. ... for my tank. ...
    (rec.aquaria.freshwater.misc)
  • Re: HELP!!! its ICK
    ... to harm any of my other fish but my mollies are down to only 2. ... advice to add salt. ... Welltruth be known mollies are a brackish water ...
    (rec.aquaria.freshwater.misc)
  • Re: Sick molly question
    ... That said they are great fish and prolific in breeding once you nail a few things. ... I have found spirulina flake to also be very good at getting mollies to look their best. ... Adding salt is harder if you have salt intolerant species in there like corys?. ... The mollies are in an outdoor tank with a fair amount of algae, so I feed flakes, dried bloodworms, and various frozen foods. ...
    (rec.aquaria.freshwater.misc)
  • Re: Salt or not?
    ... >>>Platies don't need any salt and nothing else in your tank likes it. ... >>>some if the water is very soft. ... >>>Mollies are the livebearers that really require salt. ...
    (rec.aquaria.freshwater.misc)
  • Re: HELP!!! its ICK
    ... now you have Ich attacking your Mollies. ... I ask because mollies need salt in their water. ... Where as a molly that's kept in purely fresh water (no salt) will not. ... for my tank. ...
    (rec.aquaria.freshwater.misc)