Re: [Xnews] FQDN generation
- From: Tech Zero <uselesspam@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Mon, 02 Jul 2007 00:44:00 -0600
Reality folded in on itself, and somewhere the following words from "Guy" appeared in history:
Xnews does not *use* the "suggested one" at anytime.
Unless you don't set a Token-ID...
Either it sends a MID or it does not.
If it sent a "blank" MID it would be rejected by most servers...
All news servers "sugest" a MID on POST and it's up to the client to use
that MID or not. As seen in my hamster logs:
With a Token-ID...
23:36:50 I {2fc} > POST
23:36:50 I {2fc} < 340 OK, recommended ID <f69dqj.ns.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
23:36:51 I {2fc} < 240 article posted ok <Xns9960F03739CCAInsomniac@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
...
23:36:52 D {8a4} [news.readfreenews.net] PostArticle
23:36:52 D {8a4} TClientSocketNNTP > POST
23:36:52 D {8a4} TClientSocketNNTP < 340 340 <46888ef4$0$97264$892e7fe2@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> (desired)
23:36:52 D {8a4} TClientSocketNNTP > .
23:36:52 D {8a4} TClientSocketNNTP < 240 <Xns9960F03739CCAInsomniac@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Article posted
23:36:52 I {8a4} {newsjobs news.readfreenews.net/post} Posting OK: 240 <Xns9960F03739CCAInsomniac@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Article posted (1308.msg)
X-Hamster-Info: Received=20070701233652
Server=news.readfreenews.net/post
Result=240_<Xns9960F03739CCAInsomniac@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>_Article_posted
Message-ID: <archive.Xns9960F03739CCAInsomniac@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Newsgroups: wyrm.trance.posts
Path: raven.dragonfur.ca!not-for-mail
Date: Sun, 01 Jul 2007 23:36:50 -0600
Standard post, with a token-ID set Xnews ignores any sugestions and
uses it's own generated MID. RFN "desires" a given MID too, but Hamster
quietly pass on what Xnews sent.
Without a Token-ID...
23:48:53 I {b1c} > POST
23:48:53 I {b1c} < 340 OK, recommended ID <f69eh5.2os.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
23:48:53 I {b1c} < 240 article posted ok <f69eh5.2os.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
...
23:48:54 D {848} [news.readfreenews.net] PostArticle
23:48:54 D {848} TClientSocketNNTP > POST
23:48:54 D {848} TClientSocketNNTP < 340 340 <468891c7$0$97222$892e7fe2@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> (desired)
23:48:54 D {848} TClientSocketNNTP > .
23:48:54 D {848} TClientSocketNNTP < 240 <f69eh5.2os.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Article posted
23:48:54 I {848} {newsjobs news.readfreenews.net/post} Posting OK: 240 <f69eh5.2os.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Article posted (1310.msg)
X-Hamster-Info: Received=20070701234854
Server=news.readfreenews.net/post
Result=240_<f69eh5.2os.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>_Article_posted
Message-ID: <archive.f69eh5.2os.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Newsgroups: wyrm.trance.posts
Path: raven.dragonfur.ca!not-for-mail
Date: Sun, 01 Jul 2007 23:48:53 -0600
As you can see here, Hamster sugests "<f69eh5.2os.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>"
and Xnews returns that value in it's post, placed in the headers where
only the news client should edit.
The MID is not present the SENT folder, nor is it seen in the raw file
while editing, so it is clearly added on post.
And with "add MID" turned off in Hamster...
00:01:45 I {62c} > POST
00:01:45 I {62c} < 340 send article to be posted. End with <CR-LF>.<CR-LF>
00:01:45 I {62c} < 240 article posted ok
00:01:46 D {e54} [news.readfreenews.net] PostArticle
00:01:46 D {e54} TClientSocketNNTP > POST
00:01:46 D {e54} TClientSocketNNTP < 340 340 <468894cb$0$97231$892e7fe2@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> (desired)
00:01:46 D {e54} TClientSocketNNTP > .
00:01:46 D {e54} TClientSocketNNTP < 240 <468894cb$0$97231$892e7fe2@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Article posted
00:01:46 I {e54} {newsjobs news.readfreenews.net/post} Posting OK
X-Hamster-Info: Received=20070702000146
Server=news.readfreenews.net/post
Result=240_<468894cb$0$97231$892e7fe2@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>_Article_posted
Message-ID: <archive.f69f9b.3ik.1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Newsgroups: wyrm.trance.posts
Path: raven.dragonfur.ca!not-for-mail
Date: Mon, 02 Jul 2007 00:01:45 -0600
Gota love that. Here is a case where Hamster adds the servers' "desired"
MID, since it's acting like a client. But, because it didn't get an MID
(never sugested one) it need a fictional one for the archive.
So Xnews can return a "blank" MID, in unususal situations, but defaults
to whatever the server sugests. If I was to further mess with my
Hamster settings I could "spit" the post out, unaltered, as text file,
just to see exactly what Xnews is sending in this case...
But only after some sleep.
--
__ __| | __ __| | __ /
| \ -_) | -_) _| \ / -_) _| _ \
_| _| _| \___| _| \___| \__| _| _| ____| \___| _| \___/
Losing quality sleep helping others on-line since 1997...
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: [Xnews] FQDN generation
- From: Guy
- Re: [Xnews] FQDN generation
- Prev by Date: Re: [slrn] color names
- Next by Date: Re: Xnews: when I post a message with an attachment
- Previous by thread: "Operation in Progress" Message
- Next by thread: Re: [Xnews] FQDN generation
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
