Re: introducing faith/religion to kids

On Mon, 09 Jun 2008 21:58:27 -0400, Ericka Kammerer <eek@xxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

We don't wait until people are adults
before teaching them math, science, or language skills. We also
shouldn't wait until they're adults to teach them to evaluate the
facts, form opinions, and speak about them. That should happen
right alongside reading "Henry and Mudge" and learning to write.

Sure. I'm asking for a *higher* standard, not a lower
one in terms of critical thinking. And there are *plenty* of
opportunities to learn critical thinking at school without being
unmannerly.

And many of those opportunities are objected to by Fundamentalists
because they involve the examination of beliefs that are *against*
their religious beliefs. Anytime you examine ethical dilemmas, you
risk overturning various religious dogmas.

Just try presenting something like this to high school students in the
appropriate class.

http://www.goodcharacter.com/dilemma/dilemma.html

?There are certain times,? thought Lisa, ?when you know things have
gone from really bad to out of control.? The party had started out
fine, like they always do. And things got a little crazy, like they
always do. But Lisa?s friend Sarah, a small framed senior had had way
too much alcohol and had been throwing up for an hour while going in
and out of consciousness. There were no adults around and they were
miles from the nearest town, at somebody?s vacation home.

?We need to call 911 or take Sarah to the hospital now!? Lisa said to
the group of five friends in the bathroom with Sarah.

?No way,? one of the girls said. ?We?d be in so much trouble. My
parents cannot know I?m even here! If they find out, this will be my
last time out of the house before leaving for college!?

Lisa felt more scared than ever before in her life. She felt in her
gut that Sarah was worse off than any of them could deal with, and if
they didn?t get help she might even die. But what if she was wrong?
What if everything gets better in an hour and everyone hates her for
making a huge deal out of just a ?bad situation? at a party?

The girls continued arguing. Three of them agreed with Lisa. Two of
them were adamant about dealing with it on their own. Lisa felt like
time was running out. What should she do?

**********************
This case represents the classic stereotype and a parent?s worst
nightmare. Those of us who work with teens hear modified versions of
this story more times than the average person might think. It
demonstrates how teenagers need constant reminders about calling for
help when things become dangerous. They must develop the tools to
recognize danger and to resist the pressure to downplay that danger
when the consequences could change their lives forever. It is still
mortifying to me to hear my students talk about how often they were in
a party situation over their heads and simply prayed it would work out
all right. And then, of course, there are times when it doesn?t, and
we all have had the awful experience of witnessing a few of those as
well.


--
Dorothy

There is no sound, no cry in all the world
that can be heard unless someone listens ..

The Outer Limits
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: LymeNut making Lisa out to be some crusader. Kathleen put that woman in the nut house.
    ... you are a danger to yourself or others. ... including military and government ones are relays in the whole great ... not even convinced Lisa exists. ... actually seems to have organized the protest. ...
    (sci.med.diseases.lyme)
  • Re: One-sentence-at-a-time story
    ... :>> When he awoke the Doctor found himself sitting upright in a large ... :>> wide arm and leg rests, while Sarah Jane hovered above him, looking ... Harry Potter and Lisa Simpson. ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: One-sentence-at-a-time story
    ... :>> When he awoke the Doctor found himself sitting upright in a large ... :>> wide arm and leg rests, while Sarah Jane hovered above him, looking ... Harry Potter and Lisa Simpson. ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: One-sentence-at-a-time story
    ... :>> When he awoke the Doctor found himself sitting upright in a large ... :>> wide arm and leg rests, while Sarah Jane hovered above him, looking ... Harry Potter and Lisa Simpson. ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: The way to not do Disney
    ... Almost as bad are the people who refuse to go to WDW because "its a kiddie place and there is nothing for adults." ... Lisa ... I can't even use kids as an excuse anymore since mine are grown. ... OH they know I am NUTS. ...
    (rec.arts.disney.parks)
Loading