Re: News on Peter Moran (Moron?)

TB: I stradle the fence on this one. I disagree with most of what PM
and PB write in this group, but I also think Hulda Clark is a kook.
I'm not impressed with PM's knowledge of disease and medicine, but I
also have a problem with HC's use of "poly-pharmacy", "one cure for
everything", subjective interpretations(syncrometer,etc.), her
"Unified Theory Of Disease", "Hype", etc. My opinion comes from having
read 4 of her books and owning 3 of them. On a scale of 1 to 5 , I
rate her books as a 2. I have read many orthodox and alternative
medical books and articles in the last 35 years, HC doesn't "know it
all". There is a lot of truth in HC's books but she does not have "The
Cure For All Diseases", 1995. That is a delusion and hype! If she
really had "the cure for all diseaes"(1995), why does she keep writing
more books? Greed? Money? Delusions? !!!!!

Paul

On Jan 9, 6:59 pm, jurim...@xxxxxxxxx wrote:
On Jan 9, 6:51 am, Citizen Jimserac <Jimse...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

On Jan 8, 9:56 pm, "Peter Moran" <pmo...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

"rpautrey2" <rpautr...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message

news:9955e9a1-18e9-43fe-81f8-44ed22828ec1@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
How did you obtain the information in this post? Are you sure it is
factual? PA

On Jan 8, 5:49 pm, Borked Pseudo Mailed <nob...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote:

Moron claims to be a "retired" surgeon from Australia.
He is a retired surgeon from Australia. His retirement,
however, was not elective. It seems Moron had a number
of complaints from patients (victims) and his regulator
felt compelled to "early retire" him.

Case closed...Peter Moran is a Moron! Thank you Tim Bolen!

Herein a clue to the tactics of some of those promoting quackery.    It was
finding material  like this all over the Internet that finally provoked
Barrett into suing Ilena Rosenthal and others.  Any  who condone this kind
of bald-faced lying should be ashamed of themselves.

I suppose I have to respond.  I am a retired surgeon,  although still
registered as a specialist in the state of Queensland and able to reactivate
my practice  at any time after fulfilling some conditions.   This, along
with the fact that I have NEVER  been the subject of any complaint, can be
confirmed by contacting the Medical Board of Queensland.    Anyone is also
welcome to  try the Queensland Branch of the Australian Medical Association
the Queensland Health complaints tribunal, other bodies where complaints
against doctors can be directed..

I have also never been sued by anyone, but I am not sure how that can be
proved.

PM

Peter, I needed no proof of your background.  Although I often
disagree with your opinions, it is clear from your well reasoned
postings and clear and patient explanations that you are a person
with significant medical experience and knowledge and we
are all of us grateful for your valuable and interesting postings.

Thanks
Citizen  Jimserac- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Citizen Jimerasac:

I disagree with your general analysis of Peter Moran's qualifications
to say the things he says in his posts.  He, simply, doesn't seem to
have, or  can provide, any science or practical experience, as
evidenced by two things:  (1)  his inability to step up, and back up,
his defamatory statements about world-renowned scientist/author Hulda
Regehr Clark PhD by showing us, line by line, chapter by chapter of
her book, where she is a "charlatan."  (2)  Moran failed the
tranparency test when he refused to provide the names, and medical
records, of all of the patients he claims to have served (if he ever
actually did - and I have real doubts) that would demonstrate his
"expertise" to judge others.

Concerned in California...

Tim Bolen
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: News on Peter Moran (Moron?)
    ... confirmed by contacting the Medical Board of Queensland. ... the Queensland Health complaints tribunal, ... I disagree with your general analysis of Peter Moran's qualifications ... If someone makes criticism of something ...
    (misc.health.alternative)
  • Re: News on Peter Moran (Moron?)
    ... I disagree with most of what PM ... rate her books as a 2. ... Hulda cares nothing about money. ... >> confirmed by contacting the Medical Board of Queensland. ...
    (misc.health.alternative)
  • Re: _Verum Et Factum Convertuntur_ (or: Surprised By Syntax)
    ... >> people who in the past have written articles or books, ... >> You never seem to disagree with your authorities. ... familiar facts", instead of writing down the facts directly, so we all ... Why would anyone go to a newsgroup and look for references to books he ...
    (sci.lang)
  • Re: Dark Protagonists -- are they the answer?
    ... Do you disagree? ... you would naturally prefer books that support your ... with unhappy endings present a very simple story relity which ... ... The most important villain explicitly did not start out as a villain. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.composition)
  • Re: Steelhead Fly Tying Manual posted in a.b.e-book
    ... I also disagree with the present copyright situation. ... The first attempt to upload was incomplete and I cancelled it ... I have one of your old books titled "Steelhead Fly Tying Manual" by Tom ...
    (rec.outdoors.fishing.fly)