Re: Alte, einfache Simulationssoftware gesucht (aehnlich KSimus aber Win)
- From: Heinz Schmitz <HeinzSchmitz@xxxxxxx>
- Date: Fri, 04 Sep 2009 11:42:06 +0200
Ralf-Rainer Ploog wrote:
ATANUA scheint mir für Deinen Zweck auch gut zu sein.
Die Beschreibung fand ich sehr interessant zu lesen:
http://sol.gfxile.net/files/atanua080326.pdf
Für Lehrer ist sicher auch dieser Abschnitt aufschlußreich [:-)]:
"6 Homework Validation Tool
There was one unexpected request from the teachers after the
first versions of Atanua were in testing. Several teachers
requested some way of detecting whether students were
copying homework from each other, and submitting it as their
own. Even though making such a system foolproof was
impossible, some kind of implementation was clearly still
desirable.
The only way to make such a tool work would be to require
constant network connection and to keep remote copies of
everything. This was, however, not feasible.
Instead, a simple validation scheme was implemented, based on
saving timestamps of actions in the save file.
By analyzing these time stamps, as well as components used, it
is possible to give a fairly accurate analysis on how
identical different save files are. As an additional side
effect, the approximate time that was spent working on a
circuit can be estimated.
It would be simple to expand this mechanism by using stronger
hashing algorithms, encrypt the design files, store the undo
data, etc, but none of these approaches would seriously
increase the difficulty of ?hacking? the design files, since
the users have access to the tool which creates the files. On
the other hand, doing any of the above would have negative
side effects.
While the system is relatively simple, hacking it would most
likely require more knowledge and effort than simply doing the
homework. Additionally, people interested in hacking the
validation system are most likely the ones who are also
interested in the subject, and thus not likely to try to
cheat. In order to reduce the chances of cheating, the
analysis tool and further details are only available to
teachers and only on request.
Grüße,
H.
.
- References:
- Re: Alte, einfache Simulationssoftware gesucht (aehnlich KSimus aber Win)
- From: Ralf-Rainer Ploog
- Re: Alte, einfache Simulationssoftware gesucht (aehnlich KSimus aber Win)
- Prev by Date: Re: Mal was zum Lachen...
- Next by Date: Re: Blisterverpackungen -> Re: Halogenlampen
- Previous by thread: Re: Alte, einfache Simulationssoftware gesucht (aehnlich KSimus aber Win)
- Next by thread: RJ45-Kupplung
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|