Re: Do hard disks get less tolerant to heat as they age?



Rod Speed wrote:
Markus <markus4412@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote

Okay... So I assume the best thing for me to do would
be to remove the disk from its enclosure and connect
it to a friends PC, to check its SMART status?

That wont tell you what temperature it gets up to in that case.

The enclosure the hard disk currently has is simply a plastic rim
around the hard disk itself, with aluminum panels flush with the top
and bottom of the hard disk, plus a tiny bit of room at the front for
the usb & firewire interface circuitry; the clunking still occurs even
when I remove the hard disk from its enclosure; so if I connected this
raw hard disk (or even with as much of the enclosure around it as
possible, to a dangling out IDE cable from a PC; so that the hard disk
itself remained in the open and not cooled by any of the PC fans, would
this give an accurate report?

Thanks for your help so far by the way(!).

No problem, thats what these technical groups are all about.

The depth of expertise available in this newsgroups is very impressive;
it makes tech support lines pale in comparison.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Possibly OT?
    ... if you are just looking to add this 'new' hard disk as additional storage ... then the most practical thing to do is purchase an external enclosure to ... external usb enclosure, which will also come in hand for transferring data ...
    (alt.sys.pc-clone.dell)
  • Re: SATA - PATA Bridge Trouble
    ... >> enclosure, you cannot conclude that is going to overheat and fail. ... >> resistance exists between hard disk and enclosure. ... > For starters, I have boxes full of OneTouch cases, the hard drives from ... External surface of enclosure dissipates heat. ...
    (comp.sys.ibm.pc.hardware.storage)
  • Re: Software advice please
    ... You can plug your hard disk directly into the ... enclosure, then separate hard drives and swap them. ... Put the bare disks on the shelf in their anti-static bags. ... WalMart has TDK T-120s for $1. ...
    (rec.video.desktop)
  • Re: Help recovering information from Windows
    ... Beg borrow or buy a USB HDD enclosure, ... Extract the hard disk from your laptop (it ... then attach the ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: Win98 reading NTFS (XP) external drive...
    ... "Winux P" wrote in message ... > I have a 60GB external hard disk I use for backups and such. ... > computer has win98 on her laptop. ... > friends laptop to read the external disk? ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.general)